•
Moses Springer, 1876–1877 •
George Randall, 1878 •
Christian Kumpf, 1879–1880 • Benjamin Devitt, 1881–1883 •
George Moore, 1884 •
William Snider, 1885–1886 • Jacob Conrad, 1887 • Christian Kumpf, 1888–1889 • George Moore, 1890 • William Snider, 1891–1892 • Walter Wells, 1893 • Robert Y. Fish, 1894 •
Simon Snyder, 1895–1897 • Jeremiah B. Hughes, 1898 • George Diebel, 1899–1900 • David Bean, 1901–1903 • Jacob Uffelmann, 1904–1905 •
Edward F. Seagram, 1906–1907 • John Fischer, 1908 • Andrew Weidenhammer, 1909 • Levi Graybill, 1910–1911 • John B. Fischer, 1912–1913 • John R. Kaufman, 1914–1915 • Dr.
William L. Hilliard, 1916–1917 • William H. Kutt, 1918–1919 • Daniel Bohlender, 1920–1921 •
William G. Weichel, 1922–1923 • William Henderson, 1924–1925 • William D. Brill, 1926–1928 •
Louis F. Dietrich, 1929–1930 • William Uffelman, 1931 • Daniel Bohlender, 1932 • Walter W. Frickey, 1933–1934 • Henry E. Ratz, 1935–1936 • Wes McKersie, 1937–1940 • William D. Brill, 1941–1942 • Frank B. Relyea, 1943 •
Albert R. Heer, 1944–1946 •
Wilfred L. Hilliard, 1947 ==City of Waterloo==