The events occurred in fact, evidently with both Elliot and Bothwell at least wounding each other. The various accounts agree that Bothwell wounded Elliot first, who notwithstanding his wounds, managed to wound Bothwell in return to such a degree that he was near death and unable to continue the fight. This wounding of Bothwell apparently also led to
Mary, Queen of Scots life being endangered. On her way to see Bothwell, she almost perished in a mire, and subsequent to her strenuous ride (fifty miles in a single day), she became extremely ill, apparently with
pneumonia. The wounding of Bothwell by John Elliot of Park is mentioned in the Scottish chronicle called the
Diurnal of Occurrents. In this account, Elliot was captured and then shot by Bothwell outside
Hermitage Castle as he tried to escape. Elliot, according to the
Diurnal, died of his wounds on 7 October 1566. An English
border warden wrote that Bothwell had shot him "through the thigh with a dag". According to the diary of Robert Birrel, Elliot's head was sent to Edinburgh. A poem by Sir
Richard Maitland mentions Elliot as a Liddesdale reiver.
George Buchanan, perhaps to shame Bothwell, mentions in his
Detectio only that he was wounded by a nameless thief. In September 1569, a John Elliot of Park signed a pledge for good behaviour with
Regent Moray on behalf of himself and the whole Park branch of the family. ==References==