In May 1510,
Zhu Zhifan, Prince of Anhua, led a rebellion in Shaanxi, taking advantage of the opposition to Liu's reforms. In response, the Emperor sent one of the "Eight Tigers",
Zhang Yong, to lead the army against the rebels. Additionally,
Yang Yiqing, an official familiar with local affairs, was also sent to Shaanxi. However, the rebellion was crushed by local forces before they even arrived. During the march, Yang convinced Zhang that he was in danger of being overthrown by Liu in a palace coup. After returning to Beijing, Zhang joined forces with the other six "Tigers". On 13 September 1510, they accused Liu of treason, claiming he planned to assassinate the Emperor and place his own great-nephew on the throne during the funeral of Liu's recently deceased brother, scheduled for 17 September. Despite the Emperor's initial reluctance to believe in Liu's betrayal, he was finally convinced. The next day, Liu was transferred to Nanjing and his property was confiscated. When the Emperor saw the weapons and vast treasures that Liu had accumulated, he ordered his execution, despite Liu's claims of innocence. On 16 September, Liu was arrested, and his three-day execution by
lingchi, or "slow slicing", began on 27 September. Historians have varying accounts of the size of Liu's treasure. For example, Goodrich reports that it consisted of 300,000
liang of gold, 50 million
liang of silver, and 20
bushels of precious stones. Meanwhile, Barmé claims that the treasure included 2.5 million
liang of gold and silver, two gold suits of armor, 25 pounds of precious stones, 3,000 gold rings and brooches, 500 gold plates, and over 4,000 jeweled belts. Eberhard's account differs even more, stating that the treasure contained 57,800 pieces of gold, 240,000 gold bars (each ten times heavier than a liang), 791,800
liang of silver, 5 million silver bars (each weighing five
liang), 3 bushels of precious stones, two gold armors, and 3,000 gold rings, among other items. One
liang was equivalent to 37.301 grams, meaning that 1 million
liang would weigh approximately 37.3 tons. Liu's allies were removed, and his reforms were reversed. The reform documents were also destroyed, resulting in the failure of the only substantial attempt to change the administrative structure of the Ming dynasty and expand the emperor's direct control through eunuch officials. While classical historians harshly criticize Liu's group, they did attempt to streamline the administration of the empire and prevent the decline of central authority. Despite amassing enormous personal wealth, Liu claimed to aim to prevent officials from serving their personal interests, anticipating similar efforts by
Zhang Juzheng about seventy years later. However, the fact that these reforms were initiated by eunuchs sufficed for their rejection by the conservative bureaucracy. ==References==