Early years (1999–2002) Guitarist Eddie Reyes, who had formed and played in
the Movielife, Mind Over Matter and Inside, and guitarist
Jesse Lacey of the Rookie Lot founded Taking Back Sunday in
Amityville, New York, in November 1999. The band's name was taken from a song by Long Island band The Waiting Process. Lacey moved to bass with the addition of guitarist
John Nolan. The group also included vocalist Antonio Longo of One True Thing, Lacey left the band after a personal incident with Nolan. Lacey formed
Brand New a year later. Mark O'Connell, a friend of Reyes, heard about the opening and joined the group. After recording Taking Back Sunday's
self-titled EP, Longo left the band and eventually played with The Prizefighter and the Mirror. In December 2000, Lazzara switched from bass to lead vocals. He never thought he would become the group's singer: "I remember getting into [Reyes']
Windstar with that [EP] and just driving around singing those songs, just to make myself actually do it." O'Connell suggested that the group needed a bassist, and brought in Shaun Cooper. These included
Triple Crown Records, who was apprehensive as they had just signed Brand New, and
Drive-Thru Records' offer resulted from co-owner
Richard Reines having mistaken Nolan for Lacey. Eventually, a friend of the band shared a demo with
Victory Records sales and
A&R representative Angel Juarbe.
Victory Records era: Tell All Your Friends and Where You Want to Be (2002–2005) Although other labels expressed interest in Taking Back Sunday, Victory Records encouraged them to make an album. The band's debut effort was recorded over a period of two weeks in December 2001 at
Big Blue Meenie Recording Studio in
New Jersey with producer
Sal Villanueva. Lazzara fell ill around Christmas, and the sessions were delayed one to two weeks; recording concluded in early January 2002, and ended up costing $10,000. The debut album's name was revealed in February to be
Tell All Your Friends; prior to the release of their debut, a music video for "Great Romances of the 20th Century" was released on March 4, 2002. It was directed by Christian Winters, a friend of the band. Winters made the video before the group signed with Victory, and the record company enjoyed it. and "You're so Last Summer" on November 24, 2003, following a radio release the previous September. Both videos were also directed by Winters. However, Nolan later learned the apology had been insincere, and both Nolan and Cooper officially told the other three band members they were leaving the band two days later. Nolan publicly reasoned that his departure resulted from exhaustion from touring; Lazzara reiterated this reason, and revealed Cooper had left because he did not want to be in the band without Nolan. In truth, Nolan later revealed there was constant fighting within the group, with each member feeling they were not receiving enough credit for the group's success. Taking Back Sunday underwent a short period where they were unsure what to do next, and even briefly considered breaking up. Eventually, it was decided the band would continue; the two departed Taking Back Sunday members were replaced by Breaking Pangaea frontman
Fred Mascherino on guitar and vocals as well as O'Connell's longtime friend Matt Rubano on bass. Taking Back Sunday immediately commenced work on a second album. Recording for the second album began on March 1, with
Lou Giordano at the helm as producer. Taking Back Sunday self-financed the recording sessions, At the suggestion of Giordano, the band experimented with instruments aside from the group's usual instrumentation. the new album managed to do well commercially; preceded by the single "
A Decade Under the Influence" on June 22,
Rolling Stone listed
Where You Want To Be as one of the top fifty records of 2004. Instead of spending marketing money towards trying to get radio play, Victory Records deployed a
street team handing out sampler CDs and fliers to promote the album. It remains Victory's highest chart peak for an album.
Tom DeLonge of
Blink-182 directed the music video for "This Photograph is Proof (I Know You Know)"; Blink-182 had invited the band to open for them during their North American tour in 2004. Taking Back Sunday toured frequently for eight months in support of
Where You Want to Be, including an appearance at the
Reading Festival. During this time, they were on a co-headlining tour with
Jimmy Eat World; they would introduce two new tracks, "Error: Operator" and "What's It Feel Like to Be a Ghost?" during these shows. it was later added to the
film's soundtrack as well. On September 21, 2005, it was announced that Taking Back Sunday had begun recording their third album. With
Eric Valentine at the helm, recording commenced at Barefoot Studios in
Los Angeles. The group chose Valentine because he had produced
Queens of the Stone Age's
Songs for the Deaf (2002) and
Third Eye Blind's
self-titled album (1997). The band had attempted to secure Valentine as producer for
Where You Want to Be, but were unable to. During the sessions, the band strived to take a more rock-oriented instrumental approach without compromising their whole compositional style. By January 2006, the album was completed, and the album's title was revealed the following month as
Louder Now.
Louder Now was released on April 25, 2006 through
Warner Bros. Records. On October 30, 2006, the band's former record label, Victory Records, released
Notes from the Past, which featured four songs from
Tell All Your Friends, six songs from
Where You Want To Be, and two B-sides:
The Ballad of Sal Villanueva and ''Your Own Disaster ('04 mix)
. The band then released Louder Now: Part Two'' on November 20, 2007, a DVD of unreleased live concert footage from their show at
Long Beach Arena in
Long Beach, California, which included special features such as the video for "Twenty-Twenty Surgery", made to be released in Europe. In
2007, the band contributed the song "
What's It Feel Like to Be a Ghost?" to
the soundtrack for the
science fiction action film Transformers, although the song did not appear in the film.
Departure of Fred Mascherino and New Again (2007–2010) In October 2007, the band announced that Taking Back Sunday and guitarist
Fred Mascherino would be parting ways, which came after he decided to focus on his then upcoming solo album with
The Color Fred. He was later replaced by Matthew Fazzi, who would provide guitar and backing vocals. Mascherino went on to reveal in later interviews: "There were just problems between the five of us about writing, who was going to do it and how we were going to do it, we weren't being very productive because we were fighting too much about that stuff. The band was more about cooking food than making music." This statement inspired the band to write the track "Capital M-E", which features lyrical references to Mascherino's departure and the comments he made afterward. In 2010, Fred Mascherino posted a picture of himself and Adam Lazzara with the caption, "Today was a good day" indicating that he and Lazzara have since made up and are on good terms again. On November 6, 2008, Taking Back Sunday revealed in
Rolling Stone that their fourth studio album was to be titled
New Again and would feature the tracks "Winter Passing", "Lonely Lonely", "Catholic Knees", and "Carpathia". They stated that "Winter Passing" was "... a slow dance like the last song at your 8th grade dance [that] moves more like an
R&B tune than a
rock and roll song", and that "Carpathia" will include the first bass solos in any Taking Back Sunday song. They also commented that "Catholic Knees" is "one of the heavier songs we've ever written", and that "Lonely Lonely" is "relentless – two and a half minutes of punching you in the face". In the build-up to the release of
New Again, the band released a number of tracks—the first of which was "Carpathia"—on December 21, 2008, as free digital downloads to those who purchased the band's
Christmas holiday set, with a physical limited vinyl release of the track as well as a live version of "Catholic Knees" released on April 18, 2009. The title track "New Again" followed as a free single download from the band's website on April 16, 2009, followed by the first full single "Sink into Me", released on April 20, 2009, premiering on
BBC Radio 1's
Zane Lowe show, and being made available digitally short after. On May 16, 2009, "Everything Must Go" was released to stream on the band's
MySpace. Every Monday, the band released a new song on their MySpace from
New Again labeling it "New Music Monday". During their tour supporting
New Again, the band played in Dublin, Ireland where guitarist Matt Fazzi fractured his foot. Despite this, the show in Belfast, Northern Ireland went on and the rest of the tour was completed, which included stops in the UK at
Sonisphere Festival and the
Kerrang! awards show. On August 18, 2009, the band released a digital live album entitled ''Live from Bamboozle '09''. The album consists of 13 live tracks recorded at
The Bamboozle, where they played in May of the same year. In September 2009, the band announced they will be co-headlining with
The All-American Rejects and
Anberlin for a full US tour. They are also set to release a live acoustic DVD around spring 2010 following the tour. "Winter Passing" did not make it to the final release of
New Again; it was released on February 12, 2010 on their official website. Throughout February and March the band played the Australian Soundwave tour, playing songs from various albums to crowds of almost 30,000.
Taking Back Sunday and lineup change (2010–2012) On March 29, 2010, Matt Rubano and Matthew Fazzi announced that they were no longer members of Taking Back Sunday. On April 12, after some social media hints, the band made an official announcement confirming that John Nolan and Shaun Cooper had re-joined the band. It was announced that they would soon begin the recording process of their fifth studio album with
Louder Now producer
Eric Valentine. On the same day, Adam Lazzara did an interview with
Alternative Press, in which he discussed how the original line-up got back together and how both Matt Rubano and Matt Fazzi were not fired, but rather "let go". The band finished writing in El Paso with around 15 songs completed, according to Mark O'Connell. Pre-production on the new album began on August 17, 2010, the same day their live acoustic album
Live from Orensanz was released. On December 20, 2010, the band put out a new Christmas song entitled "Merry Christmas I Missed You So Much". On April 6, 2011, the band played at Maxwell's in
Hoboken, New Jersey, to record footage for an upcoming video for the song "El Paso". "Faith (When I Let You Down)" was released as the official first single from the album on May 3, 2011, with an acoustic version of "Great Romances of the 20th Century" as the b-side. On June 7, 2011, the second official single "This Is All Now" was released on
iTunes, with the b-side being an acoustic version of "Ghost Man on Third". On June 26, 2011, in an interview with Robert Herrera of Punkvideosrock.com, Mark and Shaun stated that the reason they returned to their original lineup was because they no longer felt it was Taking Back Sunday without the original members. Mark stated they were miserable as a band, weren't having fun, and didn't like the direction the band was going so they decided to reach out to the original members and after meeting with the band in Texas found that "the chemistry was still there." On July 8, 2011, Taking Back Sunday released an official music video for "Faith (When I Let You Down)". On November 3, 2011, Taking Back Sunday released an official music video for "You Got Me". Taking Back Sunday played Warped Tour 2012 at all locations. In honor of
Record Store Day 2012, the band released a limited press vinyl LP entitled "We Play Songs", featuring four live acoustic tracks.
TAYF10 anniversary tour (2012–2013) Taking Back Sunday embarked on a "Tell All Your Friends" 10th anniversary tour for 2012, during which the band performed their debut album in its entirety. The full US tour featured Bayside as main support, with Transit, Man Overboard and Gabriel the Marine as special guests. An audio and video recording of the acoustic version of the tour was released for digital download through the band's website on June 18, 2013. On June 7, 2013, 2:33PM, Taking Back Sunday took to Twitter to confirm that the recording of their 6th studio album had begun; they tweeted: "Phase one of recording the new record starts now... Happy Friday!" The band, who are working alongside producers Marc Jacob Hudson and Ray Jeffrey, have confirmed that pre-production of the 6th studio record has been completed, and that drum and bass tracking has begun. On August 29, 2013, Adam Lazzara and John Nolan performed an acoustic set at the Leaky Lifeboat Inn, in Seaford, New York, where they debuted a new song with a working title, "The Bird You Cannot Change". From October 25 through November 2,
Underoath vocalist
Spencer Chamberlain began filling in on lead vocals following the premature birth of Adam Lazzara's son. On November 8, Lazzara and Nolan performed at the
Staller Center for the Arts at Stony Brook University as an acoustic act. This featured the appearance of a Stony Brook violinist named Dylan Ebrahimian who also will appear on Taking Back Sunday's next album due in 2014.
Happiness Is, Tidal Wave and departure of Eddie Reyes (2014–2019) On January 11, 2014, Taking Back Sunday revealed that a new album,
Happiness Is, was available for pre-order on iTunes, as was a new track: "Flicker, Fade".
Happiness Is was released on March 18, 2014, through
Hopeless Records. On June 27, 2016, the band's next album,
Tidal Wave, was announced for release on September 16. Material for the album was written in between tours for
Happiness Is. On April 13, 2018, it was announced that founding guitarist Eddie Reyes has parted ways with the band. This was later confirmed by Reyes, stating the reason for his departure was due to his battle with alcoholism and hoped to join the band again in the future. In the meantime, he has also stated to have started a new band. On the subject of ever touring with previous members of Taking Back Sunday, John Nolan said in an interview: "I don't think that's something that really interests us. This lineup has been together for three albums now and we're really focused on continuing to develop and evolve together. Revisiting old songs with past band members just seem like an exercise in nostalgia." On January 11, 2019, the band released a compilation album called
Twenty to celebrate their 20th anniversary, along with a worldwide tour. In 2019, for their 20th Anniversary tour, the band employed the use of a specially made coin to flip at shows in locations where they were playing two nights in a row. The coin toss decided the second album to be played the first night of the pair of shows, either
Louder Now or
Where You Want to Be. "Tell All Your Friends" was played each night. In December 2019, John Nolan said that the band was not currently on a label, indicating that they left Hopeless Records.
152 and O'Connell's departure (2020–present) In February 2020, the band returned to the studio to begin work on their eighth studio album. Further sessions were cancelled or otherwise postponed, however, on account of the
COVID-19 pandemic. In April 2021, Lazzara and Nolan collaborated on a song with
Q-Unique, DJ Eclipse and the
Wu-Tang Clan's
Cappadonna, titled "Verrazzano Villains". In October 2021, the band shared a cover of the
Weezer song "
My Name is Jonas". The band returned to touring in 2022, including UK dates with
Alkaline Trio and North American dates in support of
My Chemical Romance. Also in 2022, the band reissued
Tell All Your Friends for its 20th anniversary, and released two collaborative singles: "
Loved You a Little" with
The Maine, and "Just Us Two" with
Steve Aoki. In June 2023, the band released their first original new music in over four years, a single titled "The One".
152, the band's eighth studio album, was released on October 27, 2023, via
Fantasy Records. The band performed at
Coachella 2024 in April. On December 7, 2024, Fred Mascherino performed with the band for the first time since 2007, at the Starland Ballroom in Sayreville, New Jersey. Mascherino played guitar and sang "Liar (It Takes One to Know One)" and "MakeDamnSure," trading vocals with Nolan on the latter. In December 2024, former member Eddie Reyes claimed on a podcast that drummer Mark O'Connell, who had been in Taking Back Sunday since 2001, was no longer in the band. O'Connell formally announced his departure on January 7, 2025. He wrote in a statement, "Over the past few years, I’ve focused on my family and personal growth, including committing to my sobriety. Unfortunately, during this time, I didn’t always feel the support I needed from those I thought of as brothers, and creative differences made it hard to move forward together." In July 2025, Fred Mascherino announced that he would rejoin Taking Back Sunday in a touring capacity while John Nolan is taking "a short break from touring to spend time with his family". The band will also play festival dates as a six-piece, with Lazzara, Nolan and Mascherino all sharing vocal duties. That same month, O'Connell sued his former bandmates for defamation, alleging that Taking Back Sunday spread false damaging claims about O'Connell and withheld royalty payments from him. In February 2026, the band was announced as part of the lineup for the
Louder Than Life music festival in
Louisville, scheduled to take place in September. In February and April of 2026, Taking Back Sunday announced not only they would be performing at
Red Rocks Amphitheater with
Fred Mascherino but also, they would do a 2026 Summer tour with
Bayside (band) and a Fall tour with
Thrice and
Saves the Day. ==Musical style and influences==