PopMatters said, "'Living After Midnight' still sticks in the craws of some fuddy-duddy
metal old-timers, but as trite as this little party anthem is, its hook is irresistible and glorious, the sound of a band learning that it never hurts to have a little fun once in a while. The song is oddly clean-cut, hedonism rendered a little innocent, and kind of sweet."
BBC agreed it, "epitomised the new breed of radio friendly metal". In 2012,
Loudwire ranked the song number five on its list of the 10 greatest Judas Priest songs, calling it, "Perhaps the greatest Judas Priest song to sing along with," and in 2019,
Louder Sound ranked the song number three on its list of the 50 greatest Judas Priest songs. ==Cover versions==