The Boston Globe opined that Whitley's "unusual bent-note singing and spare but deeply affecting lyrics mark him as a true discovery."
The New York Times wrote that the album "is about dust, danger, two-lane roads and barren landscapes; it's about running and feeling like an outlaw, not so much in the literal as in the emotional sense of being detached and therefore free, of being at home on the outskirts of right and wrong."
Living with the Law was named ninth best album of 1991 in the
Pazz & Jop critics poll. It is listed in Tom Moon's 2008 book,
1,000 Recordings to Hear Before You Die. Whitley later dismissed his first album as "too polished". ==Track listing==