Young began writing songs for
Living with War in a
Gambier, Ohio, hotel room while visiting his daughter at her
college. While retrieving
coffee from a
vending machine early one morning, Young saw the front page of a
USA Today issue documenting a surgery room on an airplane flying seriously wounded US soldiers from Iraq to
Germany.
Time Out London similarly proclaimed the record to be an "anti-Bush
folk-metal tirade". Young was inspired to write an album critical of American policy due to a lack of other, younger artists doing the same: "I was hoping some young person would come along and say this and sing some songs about it, but I didn't see anybody, so I'm doing it myself. I waited as long as I could." In a New York Times interview, he compares the album's style to that of
broadsides, an older style of protest music: "They had these songs that everybody knew the melodies to. They'd just write new words, and the minstrels would be traveling around spreading the word. Music spreads like wildfire when you do it that way." The rush release and the political nature of the tracks are also comparable to Young's 1970 song "
Ohio". In a May 2007 interview with
Rolling Stone's
David Fricke, Young rejects the comparison: ==Recording==