The two P1s were only ever used between
New England and Ferme Park, the only route deemed suitable for them by the Operating Department. In practice there were issues with running such large trains with such powerful engines. The large three-cylinder engines required a considerable effort on the part of the fireman and the booster was known as particularly hungry for steam requiring even more coal. As a result, turns firing the P1s were considered as ones to avoid. It was also found that the heavier trains that the P1s could handle were too long for many of the passing loops resulting in delays to passenger trains. The result was that they were considered uneconomic as they were generally used in hauling trains of less than the for which they were built. In 1934, No. 2394 was experimentally tried on the 07:45 am semi-fast passenger train from
Kings Cross to
Peterborough as part of the planning stage for
P2 class locomotive 2001 ''Cock o' the North''. Although the engine was able to reach a maximum speed of , this put too much stress on the fireman who later commented that he was thankful not to have been going beyond Peterborough. In 1942, both engines were overhauled and their original boilers, then in very poor condition, were replaced with A3-type boilers and their cylinder diameter was reduced to , leading to an increased tractive effort of The valve motion was retained in its original short-lap travel configuration. The rebuilding of no. 2394 took place in November 1942, after which it was intended to reclassify the locomotive P1/2. Before this reclassification could take place, no. 2393 was in the process of undergoing a similar rebuild, this being completed in January 1943, so the need to distinguish the two variants passed and both remained as Class P1. Due to the reduction of heavy freight trains after the Second World War, both engines were withdrawn and scrapped by
Edward Thompson in July 1945, the first Gresley locomotives to be withdrawn and scrapped by intention. The six-wheeled tenders were modified with standard dragboxes to run behind new
Thompson Class B2 4-6-0s Nos 2815
Culford Hall and 1632
Belvoir Castle, while the boilers were removed and fitted to Gresley A1s No. 2557
Blair Atholl and 2565
Merry Hampton during their conversion from Class A1 to Class A3. ==References==