Bryan Buss from
AllMusic complimented the song as "a pretty
ballad that showcases her songwriting skills, her clear voice, and her talent on the piano." A reviewer from
People Magazine stated that Gibson "fares well with torchy ballads" such as "Lost in Your Eyes". Betty Page from
Record Mirror wrote, "Golden larynxed Debs hits us with the big moodsome ballad, proving that she's shaping up to be the
Barry Manilow of the Nineties. She's obviously trying to shed the popcorn and candyfloss image already, but she's a bit too
Minnie Mouse to carry off the sweeping epic just yet. Still, we all had a bit of a weep over the tinkly piano." William Shaw from
Smash Hits felt that "she is crooning along to this creaky ballad that some ageing songstress like
Elaine Paige or
Elkie Brooks would feel comfortable with." == Music video ==