Pearlman became fascinated with the success of the
New Kids on the Block, who had made hundreds of millions of dollars in record, tour and merchandise sales. He started Trans Continental Records in early 1992 with the intent of mimicking their
boy band business model. The
record label's first band, the
Backstreet Boys, consisted of five unknown performers selected by Pearlman in a $3 million talent search. Management duties were assigned to a former New Kids on the Block manager,
Johnny Wright, and his wife Donna. The Backstreet Boys became the
best-selling boy band of all time, with record sales of 130 million, hitting
gold, platinum, and diamond in 45 countries. Pearlman and the Wrights were then introduced to
NSYNC, which was formed by
Chris Kirkpatrick. Pearlman and the Wrights funded and managed NSYNC in a very similar fashion, selling over 70 million records globally. With these two major successes under his belt, Pearlman had become a music mogul. Other boy bands managed by Pearlman were
O-Town (created during the
ABC–
MTV reality television series
Making the Band),
LFO,
Take 5,
Natural,
Marshall Dyllon (co-created with
country music artist
Kenny Rogers)
Band lawsuits With the exceptions of US5 and Marshall Dyllon, all of the musical acts that worked with Pearlman sued him in
federal court for
misrepresentation and
fraud. All cases against Pearlman either have been won by those who have brought lawsuits against him or have been
settled out of court. The members of Backstreet Boys were the first to file a lawsuit against Pearlman, feeling that their contract—under which Pearlman collected as both manager and producer—was unfair, because Pearlman was also paid as a sixth member of the Backstreet Boys (i.e., one-sixth of the band's own income). The band's dissatisfaction began when member
Brian Littrell hired a lawyer to determine why the group had received only $300,000 for all of their work while Pearlman and his record label had made millions. Fellow boy band NSYNC was having similar issues with Pearlman, and its members soon followed suit.
Talent scouting scam scandal In September 2002, Pearlman purchased Mark Tolner's internet-based talent company, Options Talent Group (formerly Emodel and Studio 58), which would subsequently go through several names, including Trans Continental Talent (TCT), Wilhelmina Talent Scouting, Web Style Network (WSN), Fashion Rock, and Talent Rock. Regardless of the name, all incarnations were based on the business model used by Emodel founder Ayman "Alec" Difrawi, himself a convicted
con artist, who played a principal role in running Options/TCT/WSN and setting up Fashion Rock. The companies received unfavorable press attention, ranging from questions about their business practices to outright declarations that they were
scams. The
New York State Consumer Protection Board issued an alert, naming it the largest example they had found of a photo mill scam.
California Department of Industrial Relations Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, also called ''California Labor Commissioner's Office'' declared Options/TCT/WSN in violation of California law, and several state agencies were reported to be investigating the company. In
Florida, around 2,000 complaints were filed with the then-Attorney General
Charlie Crist and the BBB, and an investigation was started by Assistant Attorney General Dowd. However, as the newly appointed Assistant AG MacGregor was unable to find "any substantial violations", no charges were filed. Further complicating matters was that the company had since declared bankruptcy, "leaving no deep pockets from which to collect damages." By June 2004, Fashion Rock, LLC had filed a civil suit for defamation against some who had criticized Pearlman's talent businesses. The case was dismissed and closed in 2006. One of the accused, a Canadian consumer-fraud expert
Les Henderson, successfully pursued a libel lawsuit against Pearlman, Tolner, El-Difrawi and several others. Fashion Rock, LLC lived on until February 2, 2007, when its assets were sold in Pearlman's bankruptcy proceeding. Difrawi continued filing lawsuits that were all
dismissed and was most recently running Expand, Inc. dba Softrock.org aka Employer Network, from the same address as former TCT. == Ponzi scheme ==