Wightman's dancing career began at age 17, when she was known as
Lucy Johnson, and peaked when she was a headliner at the now defunct
Naked i Cabaret in Boston's
Combat Zone. "Princess Cheyenne" was a local legend in Boston. The
Boston Herald would later call her "perhaps the most famous exotic dancer ever in this town." Sports columnist Bill Reynolds called her a "cult figure." Journalist Howard Altman, reminiscing about her in the
Philadelphia City Paper, called her "Boston's favorite stripper." Although she is not named, Wightman is described in Lauri Lewin's Combat Zone memoir,
Naked is the Best Disguise: My Life as a Stripper. She competed in women's
bodybuilding contests, winning the 1993
National Physique Committee Massachusetts championship and later being featured in the May–June 1996 issue of ''
Women's Physique World. A Boston Globe reporter, writing in 1979, called her "the valedictorian of strippers." The president of the Harvard Lampoon invited her to perform at a banquet in 1982, calling her "a nice and educated girl"; a few years later, a writer in Harvard Magazine noted with interest that Wightman, "one of the premier strippers" in the Combat Zone, was working her way through college. (The Naked i Cabaret, where Wightman performed, proudly advertised its "Totally Nude College Girls Revue.") In Women's Physique World'' she was described as "Lucy Wightman: 138 I.Q., 285 Bench!" ==Psychotherapy career==