In December 1995, Peter Grant from
Liverpool Echo predicted that the popularity of the show's "magnificent seven" core characters would continue to rise in 1996. Grant noted there was "plenty more fun in store" and a "very happy new year in Hollyoaks" judging by storylines such as "Louise plunges into the world of amateur dramatics." In 2005, Grant described Louise as "the most enigmatic of the debut seven" core characters. Grant continued that Louise is "a hopeless romantic in search of the perfect man" and a "gypsy-like earth mother". He concluded that she was portrayed with "a strong interest in the supernatural and lived her life by sticking to what the horoscopes said." In 2021, Sophie McCoid and Lucy Marshall from the publication branded her a "kooky character" and "earth mother type". They added that Louise "lived in hope of finding the perfect man and paid a little too much attention to her horoscopes." Greg Taylor from
Daily Mirror branded the core seven characters a group of "smart teenagers" that the show "revolves around". Kyle O'Sullivan, also from
Daily Mirror called her a "kooky character" and a "hopeless romantic" who had a "troubled relationship with cheating and rough boyfriend Joe".
Manchester Evening News Dominic Moffitt believed Louise's role in the show was to provide "the show's comic relief for a time." They also called her "a hippie" and "free loving type character" who "enjoyed a very short life on Hollyoaks." Tina Miles of
Cheshire Live labelled Louise a "kooky character". Alina Polianskaya from the
i newspaper stated "her character was into horoscopes and mystical ideas." Nick Chalmers from
Northamptonshire Evening Telegraph wrote "Louise is nuts on anything a bit spooooky! She's at the same college as Natasha and a loyal, trustworthy friend too - what a poppet!" Stephanie Colderick writing for
Wales Online stated Louise "loved her horoscopes" and was portrayed as a "more free-spirited character" than her fellow original counterparts. An
E4.com writer called her one of the "first generation of
Hollyoaks starlets" and one of the "original
Hollyoaks gang". A writer from
The Courier observed the female friendship group and decided that Natasha and Dawn "often have to cringe at the antics of fashion fanatic Maddie" and "to wonder at their supernatural obsessed friend Louise." Of her departure episode, a
Sutton Coldfield Observer critic assessed that the character is "behaving in a fashion that is increasingly disturbing." Daniel Kilkelly from
Digital Spy stated that Louise had a "short shelf life" and that she received "a rather kooky exit storyline". He assessed that "the stars appeared to align for her when she fell for a New Age traveller called Tree." Francesca Babb from
All About Soap believed that O'Brien "was great" in the role of Louise and subsequently was surprised the actress did not rise to prominence after she left the show. Joe Steeples from
Sunday Mirror criticised
Hollyoaks writing, storylines and the cast's acting abilities. He carped on about a scene featuring Louise and Natasha discussing her sex life. Louise states "We were compatible birth signs and everything. That's why I gave myself to him." Steeples branded the writing "pure
Mills & Boon" and quipped that the executive producer, Redmond had been taking tablets that transformed him into the romance writer
Barbara Cartland. Lucy Ellman of
The Independent lambasted the role of the show's original female characters. She branded them "highly suspect" and were "given little to say, and spend their time worrying needlessly about each other." She added that they all entertain themselves "with bodings of disaster." Critiquing Louise's original story, Ellman bemoaned the scenes featuring Natasha assuming Louise would commit suicide because she had sex with a "two-timing louse" on the basis her star-sign advised her to. She further ridiculed Natasha's later concern Louise could be pregnant. Their colleague, Cole Morton minimised the importance of the original characters because they were written as "glamorous young things who live in leafy suburbs rather than urban mean streets, and have only to worry about their spots and mobile phones." ==References==