Music critics for
The Native classified "Love Don't Cost a Dime" as having the biggest hit potential on the eponymous extended play, during their first impressions of the project. In a review for
Pulse Nigeria, music critic Motolani Alake described "Love Don't Cost a Dime" as "the best song on the EP." On 25 October 2021, the song debuted at number 22 on the
TurnTable Top 50 chart; it also debuted on the Turntable Top 50 Airplay chart at number 46 on 23 October 2021 and peaked at number 15, on 27 October 2021. The song debuted at number 30 on the
Billboard U.S. Afrobeats Songs chart, and it was included on
Culture Custodians list of "5 songs to add to your playlist" in September 2021. On 12 February 2022, "Love Don't Cost a Dime (Re-Up)", featuring
Ayra Starr, debuted at 27 on the
TurnTable Top 50 chart and peaked at number 8 on 28 March 2022. It debuted on the Turntable Top Triller chart Nigeria at number 14 on 23 February 2022. The song debuted on the
UK Afrobeats Singles Chart at number 20 on 13 March 2022. As of April 2022, "Love Don't Cost a Dime (Re-Up)" had received 4.6 million streams on
Boomplay. On 11 July 2022, it debuted on the newly launched
TurnTable Top 100, an expansion of the Top 50 chart, at number 33. On 14 July 2022, following the initial launch of the Nigeria Top Afro-R&B Songs chart, "Love Don't Cost a Dime (Re-Up)" debuted at number 1. On 13 July 2022, it debuted on the newly launched TurnTable Top Streaming Songs chart, an expansion of the Top 50 Streaming Songs chart, at number 37, and debuted on the newly launched TurnTable Top Radio Songs chart, an expansion of the Top 50 Airplay chart, at number 33. ==Music video==