Brisbane Roar Herrington is a product of the youth systems of
Taringa Rovers,
Toowong FC and
Brisbane City FC, before joining the academy of
Brisbane Roar in 2019, where he completed his development. In 2023, he featured for the club’s reserve side,
Brisbane Roar Youth. On 9 September 2024, he signed a three-year scholarship contract with the Roar. He made his senior and professional debut as a starter in a 2–2
A-League Men draw against
Western Sydney Wanderers on 14 December 2024. On 28 January 2025, Herrington scored his first goal for Brisbane in a 4–3 win over
Sydney FC. He made 17 appearances during his first professional season. Herrington made his first appearance of the
2025–26 season as a substitute following a red card to
Dimitri Valkanis, helping see out a 1–0 win against
Macarthur. He went on to make a further 10 appearances, scoring once in a 3–0 win over
Newcastle Jets and keeping six clean sheets. He played his final match for Brisbane Roar on 3 January 2026, starting in a 3–0 defeat to
Wellington Phoenix. Herrington made 29 appearances for the roar across all competitions, departing for a club record fee.
Colorado Rapids On 13 August 2025, Herrington agreed to join
Major League Soccer side
Colorado Rapids ahead of the 2026 season, with the transfer set to be completed in January 2026. He signed a contract running until 2029, with a club option for an additional year. On 22 February 2026, Herrington made his Major League Soccer debut for the Rapids in the opening round of the season, playing the full 90 minutes in a 2–0 loss to
Seattle Sounders. A week later, on 28 February, he started in a 2–0 win over the
Portland Timbers, keeping his first clean sheet and scoring his first goal for the club. ==International career==