On December 6, 1865, Lucy was married to
Wendell Phillips Garrison (a son of the
abolitionist William Lloyd Garrison) in Philadelphia. Together, they were the parents of: • Lloyd McKim Garrison (1867–1900), who married Alice Kirkham in 1896. After his death she married
Frederic Wait Lord. • Philip McKim Garrison (1869–1935), who married Marian Knight. After his death, she married
Hendon Chubb, son of
Thomas Caldecot Chubb. • Katherine McKim Garrison (1873–1948), who married banker
Charles Dyer Norton,
Assistant Secretary of the Treasury and Secretary to President
William Howard Taft, in 1897. Garrison died of heart disease after a long illness culminating in paralysis on May 11, 1877, in
West Orange, New Jersey. She was survived by her husband and three children. Her story is told in a biography by musicologist Samuel Charters entitled, ''Songs of Sorrow: Lucy McKim Garrison and 'Slave Songs of the United States' ''. == Legacy ==