The character has been played by five actresses. The role was originated in 1991 by an unknown baby.
Amanda Seyfried portrayed Lucy in two episodes in December 2000, before being let go due to difficulties between her and the creators. One year later,
Peyton List stepped into the role on December 14, 2001. Lucy's popular pairing with older bad boy
Dusty Donovan (played by
Grayson McCouch) earned her many fans and a lot of publicity. List opted not to renew her contract, and her final appearance on the show was on January 24, 2005. Nearly two years later,
Spencer Grammer took over the role on May 31, 2006.
Melissa Claire Egan subsequently auditioned and tested for the role, with Grammer being cast. After six months of playing Lucy, Spencer was let go, and the character was written out. Her final airdate was December 14, 2006. On December 24, 2008, newcomer
Sarah Glendening took over the role of a grown-up Lucy. She departed from the role on January 7, 2009. Glendening returned to the role on February 26, 2009, and left again on May 13, 2009. She returned to the role once again on July 22, 2010, and left on August 13, 2010. ==Storylines==