Critical response Earth was released at a time when the
independence of the film industry in the Soviet Union from the
Communist Party was being eroded and its most prominent directors—like Dovzhenko—and critics were being criticized and purged. Soviet authorities and journalists simultaneously lauded the film for its "formal mastery" and derided it for perceived ideological shortcomings.
Pravda, the official newspaper of the Communist Party, praised the film's visual style but called its political content "false". The Soviet poet
Demyan Bedny attacked
Earth, calling it "
counterrevolutionary" and "
defeatist" in the newspaper
Izvestia.
Ippolit Sokolov, a Soviet film critic, described Dovzhenko as a "great director" but also "a petty-bourgeois artist" in his review of
Earth. Dovzhenko was so upset by the negative reaction to the film that, on the verge of a
nervous breakdown, he left Ukraine and traveled abroad to screen his films and experiment with newly developed
sound equipment available in
western Europe. Film critic
C. A. Lejeune praised the film's main section, saying that it "contains perhaps more understanding of pure beauty in cinema, more validity of relation in moving image, than any ten minutes of production yet known to the screen."
Lewis Jacobs compared Dovzhenko's work to that of
Sergei Eisenstein and
Vsevolod Pudovkin, stating that Dovzhenko "had added a deep personal and poetic insight ... [his films] are laconic in style, with a strange, wonderfully imaginative quality difficult to describe." Film director
Grigori Roshal praised the film, writing, "Neither Eisenstein nor Pudovkin have achieved the tenderness and warmth in speaking about men and the world that Alexander Dovzhenko has revealed. Dovzhenko is always experimental. He is always an innovator and always a poet." Dovzhenko's biographer Marco Carynnyk lauded the film's "passionate simplicity … which has made it a masterpiece of world cinema" and praised its "powerful lyric affirmation of life." It was ranked 88 in the 1995 Centenary Poll of the 100 Best Films of the Century in
Time Out magazine.
Legacy Earth is widely considered to be Dovzhenko's
magnum opus, and among the
greatest films ever made. The National Oleksandr Dovzhenko Film Center considers
Earth to be the most famous Ukrainian film made. and was selected as one of five films to be screened at a festival to celebrate the 70th anniversary of
UNESCO in 2015. The work received 10 critics' votes in the
2012 Sight & Sound critics' poll of the world's greatest films. The
British Film Institute said of
Earth that its plot "is secondary to the extraordinarily potent images of wheatfields, ripe fruit and weatherbeaten faces". In 2022, the film was ranked joint 243rd in the
critics' poll, tied with 21 other films. ==See also==