Shelton had wanted to be a director, but was worried that being in her mid-30s, it was too late to begin. When she saw French director
Claire Denis speak at Seattle's Northwest Film Forum in 2003, Denis revealed she was 40 when she directed her first feature film, and that revelation made Shelton realize that she still had plenty of time. In 2004, Shelton began writing and directing her first feature film,
We Go Way Back. Described as "polished" and "impressionistic", the film depicts a 23-year-old actress, Kate, confronted by her 13-year-old self. The dialog between the older and younger Kates begins in memory, and then climaxes in an
apparitional experience with the specter of her own, repressed, precocious youth. Her film
Humpday premiered at
Sundance, was acquired by
Magnolia Pictures, and has been shown at
Cannes,
SIFF,
South by Southwest and other film festivals. It opened in theaters in New York and Seattle on July 10, 2009. Her film ''
Your Sister's Sister'' premiered in 2011 at the
Toronto International Film Festival. The film starred
Emily Blunt,
Rosemarie DeWitt, and
Mark Duplass. When asked about exploring the relationship between sisters in a 2012 interview with FF2 Media's
Jan Lisa Huttner, Shelton said:Everybody has had that experience of going home for Thanksgiving and starting to act ten years old again because they're in the same situation with their parents and their siblings. So you get back into this rut again of who you were when you were first becoming a grownup. It's not until you get out that you can break out of those bonds, but we still get trapped by them when we return.
Touchy Feely premiered at
Sundance Film Festival in 2013, where it was nominated for the Grand Jury Prize. It starred
Rosemarie DeWitt,
Allison Janney, and
Elliot Page.
Laggies was the first film Shelton directed that she had not also written. The film starred
Keira Knightley and
Chloë Grace Moretz, and premiered at the
2014 Sundance Film Festival where it was acquired by
A24 Films. In 2015, Shelton was invited to join the
Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences' Director's Branch. In 2017, her film
Outside In premiered at
Toronto International Film Festival. It starred
Jay Duplass,
Edie Falco,
Kaitlyn Dever, and
Ben Schwartz. Her 2019 comedy
Sword of Trust had its world premiere at
South by Southwest. In it, Cynthia (
Jillian Bell) inherits a sword from her deceased grandfather, which he believed proves the South won the Civil War. Shelton has directed episodes for TV shows since 2009 including
The Good Place,
GLOW,
New Girl,
Mad Men,
Casual and, in 2020, the Hulu miniseries
Little Fires Everywhere, starring
Kerry Washington and
Reese Witherspoon. Shelton described her approach to comedy as doing the opposite:When we were on set, it was really essential that none of us—not the actors or myself either—think that we're in "a comedy", because that's when I find (especially with improvisation) you start reaching for jokes. You start sort of "soft-shoeing", and trying to entertain people, and I don't want that. I want us to just always be playing to the truth of the scene and I really have no idea how many laughs there are going to be. We're playing it so straight that it's really hard to tell the forest for the trees. == Influences ==