Contemporary reviews Metal Machine Music confounded reviewers and listeners at the time, with the original 1975 RCA Victor LP edition being withdrawn within three weeks of its release.
The Strangers Dave Segal later claimed it was one of the most divisive records ever, challenging both critics and the artist's core audience, similar to the reception of
Miles Davis'
Agharta album, which was issued around the same time. Rock critic
Lester Bangs wrote of
Metal Machine Music: "as classical music it adds nothing to a genre that may well be depleted. As rock 'n' roll it's interesting garage electronic rock 'n' roll. As a statement it's great, as a giant FUCK YOU it shows integrity—a sick, twisted, dunced-out, malevolent, perverted, psychopathic integrity, but integrity nevertheless." Bangs later wrote a tongue-in-cheek article about the album, titled "The Greatest Album Ever Made", in which he judged it "the greatest record ever made in the history of the human eardrum".
Rolling Stone magazine reviewed the album as sounding like "the tubular groaning of a galactic refrigerator" and as displeasing to experience as "a night in a
bus terminal". In the 1979
Rolling Stone Record Guide, critic Billy Altman said it was "a two-disc set consisting of nothing more than ear-wrecking electronic sludge, guaranteed to clear any room of humans in record time". (This aspect of the album is mentioned in the
Bruce Sterling short story "Dori Bangs".) The first issue of the first
punk rock zine simply named
Punk, featured Reed on the cover and claimed the album had presaged the advent of the punk movement.
Village Voice critic
Robert Christgau referred to
Metal Machine Music as Reed's "answer to
Environments" and said it had "certainly raised consciousness in both the journalistic and business communities" and was not "totally unlistenable", though he admitted for white noise he would rather listen to "
Sister Ray". In 2005,
Q magazine included the album in a list of "Ten Terrible Records by Great Artists", and it ranked number four in
Q list of the 50 worst albums of all time. It was again featured in
Q in December 2010, on the magazine's "Top Ten Career Suicides" list, where it came eighth overall. The
Trouser Press Record Guide referred to it as "four sides of unlistenable oscillator noise", parenthetically calling that assessment "a description, not a value judgment". Mark Deming's review for
AllMusic said that while
noise rock groups "have created some sort of context for it",
Metal Machine Music "hasn't gotten any more user friendly with time", given it "paus[ed] only for side breaks with no rhythms, melodies, or formal structures to buffer the onslaught". In 1998,
The Wire included
Metal Machine Music in its list of "100 Records That Set the World on Fire (While No One Was Listening)", with Brian Duguid writing: In a December 2017 review, Mark Richardson of
Pitchfork gave
Metal Machine Music a score of 8.7 out of 10. He describes the album as an "exhilarating" listen. Despite the intense criticism (or perhaps because of the exposure it generated),
Metal Machine Music reportedly sold 100,000 copies in the US, according to the liner notes of the 2000 CD reissue by RCA/
Buddah Records.. ==Performance==