Initial findings The Vermont State Police, who led the official investigation for the first months after Maitland's disappearance, were skeptical that
foul play was involved, considering the possibility that Maitland was a
runaway. The area surrounding the old Dutchburn house was combed on foot by police and search dogs, but nothing was found. and a 2007 flyer provided by the
FBI stated that the scene at which Maitland's car was discovered may have been staged to appear as an accident. Maitland's parents publicly speculated that she may have been abducted by multiple people, stating that it would have been difficult for a single assailant to subdue her given her jiu-jitsu training. The website was active until at least 2009. According to a March 2017 article published in the
Burlington Free Press, the reward remained available. In June 2017, however, it was reported that the reward was due to expire in early July of that year.
Allegations and affidavit In the week following Maitland's disappearance, the Vermont State Police received an anonymous tip claiming that she was being held against her will in a house in nearby
Berkshire, from Montgomery. The woman who provided the affidavit claimed that Ryans murdered Maitland during an argument over money she had lent him to purchase crack, However, Maitland would have still been 19 years old at the time of the alleged sighting, and
New Jersey state law requires patrons to be 21 and over to enter a casino, therefore, if the woman seen was in fact Maitland, it is possible that she may have started a new life under a new identity after her disappearance; this, however, is unknown, as the woman seen on video was never properly identified. In 2012, law enforcement investigated a potential connection between Maitland's disappearance and
Israel Keyes, a
serial killer who committed numerous
rapes and murders in
Alaska,
Oregon, and
Washington, as well as in Vermont and New York, where he owned property in
Constable. The FBI ruled out Keyes's potential connection to Maitland's disappearance in late December 2012, On March 19, 2016, the twelfth anniversary of Maitland's disappearance, investigators revealed to a local television station they had recovered
DNA samples from Maitland's car. The results of the DNA tests were not made public. In July 2016, the old Dutchburn house, where Maitland's vehicle had been discovered, was destroyed in a fire. In March 2022, the Vermont State Police revealed they had found a match to the DNA sample found in Maitland's car. The identity of the person has not been released, although officials did say it belonged to one of eleven people they tested previously in connection to Maitland's disappearance and "that person has been very cooperative and spoken to us." In 2024, the FBI and Vermont State Police announced a reward of up to $40,000 for information to locate Maitland, with Craig Tremaroli, the special agent in charge of the FBI’s Albany Field Office stating, "This reward money today is for information leading to her recovery [...] Someone out there may have information that can help solve this case. It's been too long and it's time to come forward." Matthew Birmingham of the Vermont State Police additionally stated, "This is not a cold case, it's an unsolved case." ==Media depictions==