The project has received support from the
Manila city government led by Mayor
Isko Moreno. President
Rodrigo Duterte also voiced his support to the project. Likewise, Secretary
Roy Cimatu, seeing the throngs of people during the September 2020 opening, said that the project received the overwhelming support of the general public. On its partial opening in September, people crowded the beach and the nearby area that physical distancing were not properly observed.
Vloggers have been posting positive updates regarding the project, which DENR Undersecretary Benny Antiporda cited as an "effective way in informing the public" about the project. Among those targeted by the criticisms were the timing of the project, which was implemented amidst the
COVID-19 pandemic, and concerns of adverse environmental effects from the laying of
dolomite on the polluted Manila Bay.
Use of public funds Three senators also voiced their opposition to the project:
Nancy Binay,
Risa Hontiveros and
Francis "Kiko" Pangilinan. Binay cited the lack of public consultation on the project, as well as the lack of study regarding the effects of the use of dolomite sands. Both Hontiveros and Pangilinan argued that the funds for the project should have been used on public health and relief goods instead.
Akbayan filed a case with the
Supreme Court to penalize the Department of Environment and Natural Resources for pursuing the project, but the petition was junked. Oceana Philippines said that the project "will be a total waste of people’s money".
Laying of crushed dolomite The DENR's Mines and Geosciences Bureau approved the extraction of dolomite, while environment committee of the Cebu provincial board said it did not issue a permit to extract and transport dolomite to Manila Bay. The Cebu provincial board directed the Cebu Provincial Environment and Natural Resources Office to investigate. The
University of the Philippines Marine Science Institute (MSI) disapproved of the laying of crushed dolomite sand for the creation of the beach, saying that this will not improve the water quality in Manila Bay and that a continuous replenishment of the sand would be expensive. The UP Institute of Biology said that
using mangroves instead of crushed dolomite rock would be better for rehabilitation, adding that the
International Union for Conservation of Nature prefers this as an effective nature-based solution. Undersecretary Antiporda did not agree with the suggestion of the UP Marine Science Institute, calling them paid hacks, and that being from a state university the state should not be paying them. Antiporda said that the government has paid UP "half a billion pesos" for consultations. Laura David, the director of UP MSI, said that the university charged the government just over 364 million pesos. Antiporda later apologized for his statement, calling UP's criticism "painful"; David accepted Antiporda's apology, and called the back and forth a "misunderstanding".
Health Department of Health Undersecretary
Maria Rosario Vergeire initially stated that inhaling dusts of the crushed dolomite would adversely affect the respiratory system. She added later that though dolomite in its bulk form is not a known health hazard, crushed dolomite are irritants that could cause "chest discomfort, shortness of breath, and coughing". Dolomite sand could also cause stomach pain and diarrhea if ingested. A toxicology expert from the University of the Philippine-Manila College of Medicine warned that crushed dolomite might contain toxic heavy metals and silica dust that may cause cancer, respiratory and kidney problems, and weakened immunity. In September 2020, fisherfolk organization Pamalakaya requested the DENR to suspend the project after the DENR suspended two dolomite mining companies in Alcoy, Cebu. The two mining firms that provided the dolomite for the Dolomite Beach, Dolomite Mining Corporation and the Philippine Mining Service Corporation, were also ordered to halt operations by Cebu Provincial Governor
Gwendolyn Garcia. == Investigation ==