Dann had been questioned by some for supporting
Capri Cafaro's successful bid to fill Dann's unexpired term in the state Senate. Cafaro, heiress to part of the Cafaro shopping-mall empire, had never won election to office. In addition, Cafaro's father, J. J. Cafaro, had pleaded guilty in 2001 to bribing then-Congressman
Jim Traficant to push legislation that would benefit his aviation-equipment company. Capri, then in her early 20s, was president of the aviation company but was not charged with any wrongdoing. In a related trial, Capri testified she had never conspired with Traficant. As of October 18, 2006, the Cafaro family had contributed $30,500 to Dann's campaign for attorney general, in addition to the $26,000 they had donated to his state Senate campaigns. Of that money, $10,000 came from J. J. Cafaro. Dann defended his recommendation of Capri Cafaro by saying he believed she was the only qualified candidate to replace him. Dann faced criticism from the
Mansfield News Journal and others for telling (
Warren, Ohio)
Tribune Chronicle reporter Steve Oravecz to "go ... fuck yourself" at a fundraiser for Democratic presidential candidate
Barack Obama. According to the
Associated Press, the Attorney General's office missed a legal deadline to join an appeal of a
Medicaid-related court decision the state government opposes. The deadline for filing the documents was Dann's inauguration day. The failure to join the appeal does not prevent the state from filing briefs in the case.
Sexual harassment scandal A
sexual harassment scandal arose during Dann's tenure as attorney general, eventually leading to his resignation. The investigation focused on allegations of sexual harassment filed by two women, Cindy Stankoski and Vanessa Stout, who worked in Dann’s office under the supervision of Anthony Gutierrez, Dann’s director of general services. In April 2008, Dann placed Communications Director Leo Jennings on paid leave pending the outcome of the ongoing investigation in his office, along with Gutierrez, pending the outcome of the investigation. Jennings and Gutierrez were non-attorney friends of Dann from Youngstown; the three shared a condominium in Columbus. Stankoski and Stout alleged that Gutierrez, who was paid $87,500 a year, repeatedly sexually harassed them. A statement from Dann released to reporters gave no details on what led to Jennings being included in the investigation. It said only: "This action comes as a result of new information received over the weekend related to the ongoing investigation into charges of sexual harassment." Dann agreed to conditionally release emails between himself and his former scheduler, Jessica Utovich. Utovich, 28, began as Dann's scheduler, but was transferred to the position of director of travel in late 2007. Upon being transferred, Utovich received a 27% pay raise.
Extramarital affair and resignation On May 2, 2008, following the firing and resignation of a number of his aides in a sexual harassment scandal, Dann admitted that he had had an extramarital affair with an unidentified subordinate in his office. However, he initially refused to resign, saying his admission and punishment were enough. In the wake of his admission, a number of Ohio papers called for Dann to resign and the
Tribune Chronicle even apologized to its readers for their endorsement of Dann during the 2006 election. On May 4, 2008, the three largest Ohio newspapers ran editorials condemning Dann.
The Plain Dealer (
Cleveland,
Ohio) opined that "Dann has turned the attorney general's office into a laughingstock" and "it's impossible to see how he can recover" The
Columbus Dispatch said Dann was "not fit to serve", and the
Cincinnati Enquirer called for Dann's resignation. The
Plain Dealer had previously reported on statements by Republicans that if Dann wouldn't step down, they could try to
impeach him. On the evening of May 5, Democratic Governor Strickland issued a statement which appeared to support Dann's impeachment should he decide not to resign. Dann showed no interest in departure, even after Strickland's statement. On May 5, 2008, the
Columbus Dispatch reported that seven separate investigations were either underway or being considered in response to misconduct at the Attorney General's office. On May 10, 2008, the Ohio Democratic Party voted to remove their endorsement of Dann, remove him of his membership in the Ohio Democratic Party Executive Committee, and call for his immediate resignation as attorney general. On May 12, 2008, articles of impeachment were filed with 42 of the 45 Democrats in the state house supporting the nine counts. At a May 14, 2008, press conference in
Columbus, Dann resigned the Office of
Attorney General of Ohio. In March 2009, Dann and his campaign were each fined $1,000 by the Ohio Elections Commission for violating campaign-finance laws by using his political account for personal cell phones for his family and for security renovations to his Youngstown-area home. In June 2009, Dann reached a plea agreement with the Ohio Inspector General, Thomas P. Charles, in which he pled guilty to a single count of misuse of campaign funds, for purchasing travel for family members to San Francisco for a vacation that was to be packaged with a political fundraiser, and paid another fine of $1000; the Commission agreed to accept the plea deal by a 5 to 1 vote. Prior to filing criminal charges against Dann’s associates, including Leo Jennings, Anthony Gutierrez and Edgar Simpson, Charles filed complaints against Dann with the Elections Commission, alleging that he illegally used his political account to pay Leo Jennings, who used the money to pay for rent and utilities for the condominium they shared with Anthony Gutierrez. Following a trial regarding different allegations relating to his tenure in Dann's office, Gutierrez was ultimately sentenced to 45 days in jail. Dann was suspended from the practice of law by the Ohio Supreme Court effective November 20, 2012, and was reinstated effective June 11, 2013. Dann now has a private legal practice in
Cleveland, Ohio, reportedly specializing in combating home foreclosures. ==Later career==