Phil Wickham of the
University of Exeter observed that "the whole point of the series is that Meldrew is the only sane voice in a mad world". Jonathan Bignell in his book
Media Semiotics observes that the reason people laugh at Victor Meldrew is not simply that his behaviour is excessive, but that it contrasts with how all the other characters in the TV series are behaving. Meldrew's name is associated with aggression or grumpiness; the journal
Age and Ageing notes that "Viewers of Victor Meldrew (
One Foot in the Grave) would not be surprised that hostility contributes to mortality in grumpy old men." Similarly,
The Daily Telegraph uses Richard Wilson's Meldrew to refer to people who enjoy "a good moan", while Jenny Turner in the
London Review of Books can observe that "the timing and rhythm (of Geoff Dyer's
Jeff in Venice, Death in Varanasi) have the flippancy of stand-up comedy. The voice has
Eeyore in it, and
Morrissey and Victor Meldrew, and could only be English and from that postwar, post-punk generation". The
BBC recalls first that "the role of Victor Meldrew transformed Scottish TV-actor Richard Wilson into a household name and award-winning comedy performer." In addition, "So popular was his character that 'Victor Meldrew' has endured as a cultural reference for any grumpy old man." And finally and more loosely, "many viewers identified with his rages at the irritants of modern life: litter, junk mail, traffic, rudeness, streetlamps and car mechanics and to some, Victor Meldrew was a champion of the people, albeit a very grumpy one." Meldrew's persona is so powerful that Richard Wilson is perceived as "99 per cent Meldrew" by at least one critic, and when taking on a serious role as Malvolio in Shakespeare's
Twelfth Night, another critic felt that Wilson's "performance was overly influenced by his desire to 'shed the Victor Meldrew stereotype'". In the modern series of
Doctor Who, after the debut of the
Twelfth Doctor, as portrayed by
Peter Capaldi, Alison Graham of the
Radio Times compared Capaldi's Doctor to Meldrew, as both were "abrasive, acerbic and [have] no truck with modern life". The third series of the
Channel 4 comedy
Father Ted features Wilson playing a fictional version of himself, and the Meldrew character's catchphrase is repeated several times during one episode. ==References==