In 1978, she moved a polling place shortly before election which prompted a complaint from then state Rep.
Bob O'Donnell which led to district attorney
Ed Rendell charging her with violating election code, leading to her arrest on election day. The charges were dropped and she sued O’Donnell, later settling with him out of court. In 1994, a judge ordered the removal of
William G. Stinson from the
Pennsylvania State Senate due to a voting scandal in the
Second Senate District, where the two Democratic commissioners including Tartaglione were accused of allowing absentee ballot packages to be distributed via Stinson’s campaign instead of directly to voters, contrary to election rules, and failing to properly timestamp and verify voter signatures. His ruling sharply criticized Tartaglione, finding her complicit in enabling the fraud, accusing her of failing to prevent and potentially facilitating misconduct. She claimed the ruling unfairly disenfranchised voters and compared it to the
Dred Scott decision. The Republication commissioner John F. Kane said he was unaware of any misconduct. ==Family in politics==