Asay was first scheduled to be executed on March 17, 2016. However, on March 2, the
Supreme Court of Florida halted the execution after the
Supreme Court of the United States ruled that Florida's death penalty laws were unconstitutional, a ruling that was made in January 2016 following
Hurst v. Florida. Asay's execution warrant had been signed by Governor
Rick Scott prior to the ruling in early January. On July 3, 2017, following months of Florida's death penalty laws being left in legal limbo, Scott signed Asay's execution warrant, scheduling him for execution on August 24, 2017. Asay was to be executed via
lethal injection. The execution method that was to be used included two drugs that had never been used before in a Florida execution:
etomidate, an anaesthetic agent used for the induction of
general anaesthesia and
sedation and which had never been used anywhere for an execution, in lieu of
potassium acetate, which had been used only once before in the United States, by accident, in an Oklahoma execution. The lethal injection combination was new, due to states struggling to acquire the drugs needed for lethal injection. His
last meal consisted of fried pork chops, fried ham, French fries, vanilla swirl ice cream, and a can of Coke. A
Florida Department of Corrections official later stated that the execution had occurred without any incident and that Asay did not speak or show any indication of pain during the execution procedure. Asay's execution marked the first time in Florida state history that a white person was executed for killing a black person, something that had never happened before in Florida since capital punishment first began in the state in 1769. However, only one of Asay's victims (Booker) was black. The other victim (McDowell) was a mixed-race man of white and Hispanic descent, but during Asay's trial, the court mistakenly believed that McDowell was also black. This caused the Supreme Court of Florida to issue a rare not long before Asay's execution, in which they acknowledged that for more than twenty years they had mistakenly believed that McDowell was black. Asay remained the only white person to be executed in Florida for killing a black person until the 2025 execution of
Samuel Lee Smithers. In 1926, a white man Britt Pringle was sentenced to death for the axe murder of a black man. He was nearly executed several times. In one instance, he came within an hour of execution, at which point his head had already been shaven in preparation for his death in the state's
electric chair. However, in 1933, Pringle was declared insane and thus unfit for execution. ==See also==