Rutter was born in
Pottstown, Pennsylvania. He attended
Radley College in the UK for one year (1949-50) on an Exchange Fellowship from the
Hill School, then studied arts at
Amherst College and law at the
University of Pennsylvania. Rutter moved to Los Angeles in 1959 and was called to the bar in 1960. He joined the Los Angeles-based lawyers
O'Melveny & Myers and later co-founded the Californian law firm Rutter Hobbs & Davidoff in 1973, specializing in family law. After retirement at the age of 75, he set up his own small practice in
Pasadena from 2010 to 2019. He was continuously on its board for over six decades and as Director Emeritus from 2007. For Chorus America he served on the board from 1987 to 1996, chairing the board from 1993 to 1995. He received Chorus America’s Michael Korn Founders Award for the Development of the Professional Choral Art in 2001. Rutter was particularly noted for commissioning new music, including
Morten Lauridsen's
O Magnum Mysterium, which he commissioned in 1994, in honor of his wife Terry Knowles (they had married two years earlier). It was the composer's first commission and its popularity made him famous. ==Personal life==