Heaven was released to critical acclaim.
The A.V. Clubs Steven Hyden, referring to how all the band members were fathers, wrote "
Heaven is a dad-rock record in a different, truer sense. It’s an album of big adult themes: the weight of responsibility, the realization that romantic infatuation is fleeting and probably bullshit, the power of fidelity and loyalty to outlast momentary sensation and passion." Hyden concluded: "After 10 years and seven albums,
Heaven finds The Walkmen in a better place." Ben Schumer of
Under the Radar also criticized the album in an otherwise positive review, writing "After 10 years together, a band typically grows more polished and mature, but it's difficult not to feel that something essential and elemental to The Walkmen's aesthetic is missing from most of
Heaven - that palpable sense of urgency on display throughout their catalogue is on display far too little." The album was listed eighth on
Stereogum's list of top 50 albums of 2012. ==Track listing==