The district attorney charged Marvin Guy with
capital murder in Dinwiddie's death and
attempted capital murder for wounding of three other officers. At the time of the incident, Bell County prosecutors sought the
death penalty for Guy.
The Washington Post reported that Guy claims he is innocent and he said police accidentally shot detective Dinwiddie, not him. In September 2022, four months after
The Washington Post’s "Broken Doors" podcast about Marvin Guy's case, prosecutors reversed course and dropped their pursuit of the death penalty. Guy believed
The Washington Post’s podcast, plus pressure from local politicians and others, led to the death penalty being taken off the table. A succession of defense attorneys and many legal motions have also contributed to delays. Several defense lawyers have been fired or quit. Marvin Guy had two defense attorneys, Michael White and Russell Hunt, before Carlos Garcia took the role in September 2015. In 2021, Guy's family was in the process of hiring another attorney. In 2019, Guy sought a medical continuance because he needed back surgery for a degenerative condition. In 2021, COVID-19 precautions delayed all jury trials in Bell County's district courts. In December 2021, Guy's defense attorneys debated over evidence and trial dates with Assistant District Attorney Fred Burns and Judge John Gauntt. Joseph Caleb, the defense attorney, requested Marvin Guy's jail phone calls and the medical examiners file. Defense attorney Mike Ware argued, "We don't have the entire medical examiner's file, including photos." Judge Gauntt ordered that the medical examiner's file, including photos be produced. == Controversy ==