1999–2006 Arsenault joined up with
Colleen Jones prior to the 1999 season. She had previously played with Jones, as her lead at the
1993 Scott Tournament of Hearts. Together with Jones,
Nancy Delahunt and
Kim Kelly, the team would achieve great success, winning 5 Canadian Championships, and 2 World Championships. After a record winning 4 championships in a row, the team would struggle at the
2005 Scott Tournament of Hearts. Finishing round robin play, with a 6-5 record, the Jones team would end up in a four team tiebreaker. They would face Sandy Comeau of New Brunswick in the tiebreaker, where the opportunity to compete for a 5th Canadian Championship was lost, when Comeau defeated Jones 9-4. For the first time since 2001, the Jones team would have to win Provincials to return to the
2006 Scott Tournament of Hearts, which they did. After an impressive showing, the Jones team would finish second place in round robin play. After losing the 1-2 Game to British Columbia's
Kelly Scott, they would meet team Canada,
Jennifer Jones, in the semi-final. Nova Scotia would lose to Canada, giving the team a third-place finish and a bronze medal. At the end of the season, the team would split up ending a successful eight-year run. With Jones, Arsenault played in every Hearts from 1999 to 2006.
2007–2013 Arsenault would join together once again with Kim Kelly, and Nancy Delahunt, adding long time Jones 5th
Laine Peters to the team. They would qualify for the
2008 Scotties Tournament of Hearts in January 2008 by defeating
Colleen Pinkney in the Nova Scotia final. They would finish 6-5 in round robin, missing the playoffs. In 2009 and 2010 Arsenault skipped her team in the Nova Scotia Scotties coming in at 6-1, and 5-2. She lost 7-4 in the 2009 final and 6-5 in the 2010 finals both times to
Nancy McConnery who went on to represent Nova Scotia at the
2009 Scotties Tournament of Hearts and the
2010 Scotties Tournament of Hearts. At the
2011 Nova Scotia Scotties Tournament of Hearts, Arsenault finished second with a 5-2 record in round robin play. She would lose the semi-final to
Heather Smith-Dacey, who would go on to win the Nova Scotia Championship and finish third at the
2011 Scotties Tournament of Hearts. In 2011 Arsenault would reunite with former Jones teammate
Kim Kelly, who joined Arsenault's team playing second. For the 2012-2013 season Arsenault and Kelly reunited with former skip
Colleen Jones, with the goal of reaching the
2014 Winter Olympics in
Sochi,
Russia. Jones throws second stones on the team, while acting as the rink's vice skip, or "mate" while Arsenault skips.
Jennifer Baxter remains on the rink at lead, while Arsenault's former third of
Stephanie McVicar, left the team to play with
Heather Smith-Dacey, and
Nancy Delahunt joined the team as the 5th. The team qualified for the
2013 Scotties Tournament of Hearts in their first season back together, and finished the event with a 5-6 record.
2013–2020 Colleen Jones left the rink in 2013, and was replaced by
Christie Gamble at second. Kelly and Gamble left the team after one season and were replaced by
Christina Black and
Jane Snyder. Arsenault finally won her first career
World Curling Tour event by winning the 2014
Gibson's Cashspiel. She followed this up by winning the
Dave Jones Molson Mayflower Cashspiel a month later. The team played in the
2015 Scotties Tournament of Hearts, and finished with a 5-6 record. They failed to return the Scotties in 2016, having lost in the final of the
2016 Nova Scotia Scotties Tournament of Hearts to
Jill Brothers. In 2016, Snyder was replaced by
Jennifer Crouse at second. The team had a disappointing record at the
2017 Nova Scotia Scotties Tournament of Hearts, finishing 3-4. After the season, Crouse and Baxter switched positions. With the new lineup order, the team won the
2018 Nova Scotia Scotties Tournament of Hearts and represented Nova Scotia at the
2018 Scotties Tournament of Hearts. There, Arsenault led her rink to a 9-2 round robin record and a spot in the playoffs. In the playoffs, she beat Northern Ontario's
Tracy Fleury before losing in the semifinal to
Kerri Einarson's "Wildcard" team, settling for bronze medal. In 2018, Crouse was replaced at lead by
Kristin Clarke. On the tour, the team won the
New Scotland Clothing Ladies Cashspiel. At the
2019 Nova Scotia Scotties Tournament of Hearts, they lost in the final to Jill Brothers. In 2019 Clarke was replaced by Arsenault's niece
Emma Logan. The team won another tour event,
The Curling Store Cashspiel. Later in the year they won the
2020 Nova Scotia Scotties Tournament of Hearts and represented Nova Scotia at the
2020 Scotties Tournament of Hearts. At the Scotties, Arsenault led Nova Scotia to a 4-3 record in pool play, but lost in a tiebreaker to British Columbia, failing to qualify for the championship round.
2020–present Following the 2020 Scotties, Arsenault announced she would be moving from
Halifax to British Columbia, where she will spend her retirement. On March 3, 2020, Arsenault announced she would be skipping
Kelly Scott's former teammates
Jeanna Schraeder,
Sasha Carter and
Renee Simons for the
2020–21 season. The team played in one event during the abbreviated season, finishing runner-up at the
Sunset Ranch Kelowna Double Cash to Team
Corryn Brown. Due to the
COVID-19 pandemic in British Columbia, the 2021 provincial championship was cancelled. As the reigning provincial champions, Team Brown was invited to represent British Columbia at the
2021 Scotties Tournament of Hearts, which they accepted, ending the season for Team Arsenault. The next season, the team again reached the final of the Sunset Ranch Kelowna Double Cash, losing to the
Kaila Buchy junior rink. They were able to compete in their provincial championship at the
2022 British Columbia Scotties Tournament of Hearts in
Kamloops from January 5 to 9. After losing to Team
Kayla MacMillan in both the A Final and 1 vs. 2 page playoff game, Team Arsenault defeated MacMillan 8–6 in the final to win the provincial championship. At the
2022 Scotties Tournament of Hearts, the team finished with a 3–5 round robin record, defeating Quebec, the Northwest Territories and the Yukon in their three victories. Also during the
2021–22 season, Arsenault skipped the British Columbia Senior Women's Team of
Penny Shantz,
Diane Gushulak and
Grace MacInnes at the
2021 Canadian Senior Curling Championships. The team finished 8–2 through the round robin and championship pools, qualifying for the semifinal. They then defeated Nova Scotia before losing to Saskatchewan's
Sherry Anderson in the final, settling for silver. ==Personal life==