In 1875, she made her first stage appearance at a benefit performance at
Macauley's Theatre in
Louisville, Kentucky, in the role of Shakespeare's Juliet The manager, Barney Macauley, was sufficiently impressed to extend the booking to a week as Juliet and further roles including Julia in
Sheridan Knowles's
The Hunchback, Bianca in
Henry Hart Milman's
Fazio, and R. L. Sheil's
Evadne. Further engagements at
St Louis,
New Orleans and
John McCullough's theatre in
San Francisco led to a contract with
John T. Ford. Starting as Lady Macbeth in his Washington theatre in 1877, she began an extensive US tour, culminating with a six-week engagement in
Edward Bulwer Lytton's
The Lady of Lyons at the
5th Avenue Theatre, New York. Critical review was mixed, but she was immediately popular with the public as "Our Mary." In 1883, after starring in an American production of
W. S. Gilbert's
Pygmalion and Galatea, she went on the London stage at the
Lyceum Theatre, remaining in England for six years to perform to much acclaim including at the Shakespeare Memorial Theatre in
Stratford-on-Avon. Her first season there, she starred in Gilbert's
Comedy and Tragedy as well as in
Romeo and Juliet in 1884. In 1887 in London she appeared in ''
The Winter's Tale'' in the double role of Perdita and Hermione (the first actress to include this innovation). In 1889, however, she collapsed on stage due to severe nervous exhaustion during a performance at Albaugh's Theatre in Washington. Some commentators, particularly in the British press, ascribed this turn of events to hostile press reviews on her return to the U.S. The author
Willa Cather went further and blamed a specifically hurtful review from a close friend. For part of her career,
Napier Lothian Jr. served as Anderson's
talent manager. ==Performances==