The
New-York Tribune gave a largely positive review of the play's original 1857 production, praising the work's departure from the tropes popular in mid-19th century
melodrama, as well as the drama's domestic atmosphere. The reviewer commended the cast's performances, with the exception of J.A. Smith, who played Vernon Lordly. An 1858 production of the play at the
Holliday Street Theatre received positive reviews in several publications, extracts of which were featured in
The Baltimore Sun. Both publications are identified only as
American and
Patriot. The reviewer writing for the former compares the play favorably to French drama, which he considers immoral, while praising what he considers the play's American atmosphere and moral sentiments. The critic writing for the latter praised both Miles's writing and the performance of
Julia Dean (Hayne), who starred as Mary. In 1881,
The American Catholic Quarterly Review characterized ''Mary's Birthday'' as an accomplished play, but one of minimal interest compared to Miles's other dramatic work. ''Mary's Birthday'' is discussed in the first volume of scholar
Arthur Hodgson Quinn's 1923
History of the American Drama. While Quinn observes that all the characters are "well known types", he was very moved by the scene between Helen and her father. == Notable performances ==