Many different entities including the
United States, the
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), several states including
Maryland, and multiple gas pipeline companies, called the
Louisiana tax unconstitutional. They declared that the tax should not be able allocate the tax to other consumers, only to the ultimate consumer. During the case's hearing of evidence, Louisiana's purposes for passing the Natural Gas Act were said to pay back the state's citizens who were affected by the damages to the state's coastal regions and to compensate citizens for the costs that the state paid to protect those resources. The act was said to violate the
Supremacy Clause by requiring FERC to determine pipeline and producer costs and by subjecting them to
judicial review. ==Decision==