Critical reception On
review aggregator Rotten Tomatoes,
Mascarpone has an approval rating of 88% based on 8 reviews. Andrew Stover of
Film Threat reviewed the film as "an open, honest, and tender drama that foregrounds the importance of retaining one's independence". On
MidnightEast, Ayelet Dekel praises the film for being "sex positive, showing different perspectives on sex, dating, and relationships". Killian Melloy of
Edge Media Network praises acting and direction: "A quintet of captivating performances, along with the zippy and emotionally resonant direction, ensure that we in the audience stay invested, and amused." Denis Harvey of
48hills writes that "there's something refreshing about its reversing the usual equation of such movies: rather than true love providing the inevitable narrative solution, here it's suggested Antonio may be better off further exploring his own still-new independence before becoming half of a couple again. This very pleasing movie's debt to
Paul Mazursky's 1978
An Unmarried Woman is made explicit when it closes on a replication of that film's final scene." For
Rolling Stone Italia, "the 'gay
dramedy' is well written and acted," while for
Mymovies.it declared that "the dialogues return a communicative dynamic alien to the straight community but precisely for this reason interesting," despite the fact that the directorial imprint is "rather conventional but never sloppy or approximate." Fabio Vittorini on
Duels writes that "the writing avowedly starts from 'types' known to the general Italian public within which it digs to provide them with a peculiar and convincing language, poised between cliché (...) and subtlety, trying in every way to balance Italian-style comedy and U.S. dramedy, coming-of-age novel and sentimental drama." Massimino de Febe of
Universal Movies notes that the novelty lies in the avowed homosexuality of the main characters, presented with such simplicity that it does not characterize the film's plot on the thematic strand, but rather makes it more neutral and thus more accessible to a wide audience.
Accolades • 2022 –
Diversity Media Awards •
Best Italian Film • 2021 –
Ortigia Film Festival •
Audience Award • 2021 –
Fabrique Awards •
Best actor for
Giancarlo Commare • Nomination for the best first-feature film director for Matteo Pilati e Alessandro Guida • Nomination for best actor for Eduardo Valdarnini • 2021 –
OUTShine LGBTQ+ Film Festival • Best Feature: Jury Award Runner-Up Fort Lauderdale Edition • 2021 –
Palm Springs LGBTQ Film Festival • Festival Favorite Award • Director's Choice Award • 2021 –
Chicago LGBTQ+ International Film Festival • Best Narrative Feature Audience Award • 2021 –
Way OUT West Film Fest • Favorite Narrative Feature • 2022 –
Etna Comics •
Uzeta Award for best screenplay for Giuseppe Paternò Raddusa, Matteo Pilati and Alessandro Guida == References ==