Mass Romantic was well received in the band's native Canada, where it won a
Juno Award for
Alternative Album of the Year. On
Metacritic, which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics, the album received a score of 87, indicating "universal acclaim".
Douglas Wolk of
Rolling Stone described
Mass Romantic as "a striking power-pop album, forty staggeringly catchy minutes of four-part harmonies and
Wall of Sound production, exploding with energy and joy", Tyler Martin of
Stylus Magazine felt that "too many misdirected ideas weigh this album down". The album charted in several best of the year lists from various critics.
Pitchfork rated it the ninth best album of 2001, stating, "Energetic, smooth, and masterfully executed,
Mass Romantic is the catchiest thing to come out in ages." The site later placed
Mass Romantic at number 91 on their list of top 200 albums of the 2000s.
Magnet magazine included the album in its "20 Best Albums of 2001" list. In
The Village Voice's
Pazz & Jop critics' poll for 2001, the album placed at number seventeen. In December 2007,
Blender listed
Mass Romantic as the 24th best indie rock album of all time. It is the second-highest Canadian album on the list behind
Arcade Fire's
Funeral, which was selected as the 6th best. == Track listing ==