Matelita fell ill in September 1895 and died peacefully in her sleep, after the illness, on 29 October 1895. Later sources claimed she died after a
kerosene lamp overturned causing her mosquito net to catch fire while she slept. This is not supported by contemporary sources of the Protestant missionaries which stated she died of illness. A son of her predecessor Alalamua,
Elisala was elected as her successor to the title Tui Manu'a in 1899. After Elisala's death, the title was abolished by the United States, which had earlier incorporated the islands as a part of
American Samoa. Matelita's brother
Chris Taliutafa Young unsuccessfully attempted to claim the Tui Manu'a in 1924. After her death, she was buried next to some of the preceding Tui Manu'a title holders and eventually her successor Elisala after his death. A marble monument was built over her final resting place. The tombstone, which is the most visible monument in the royal burial ground that is delineated by a stone enclosure, consisted of a round column on a square base. The inscriptions on the base memorializes, in both the English and
Samoan language, the life of the Tui Manu'a including the words: These are my last words to you all, "May you live in peace". This grave site known as the
Tui Manu'a Graves Monument was listed on the
National Register of Historic Places in 2015. American anthropologist
Margaret Mead, who conducted research in Samoa between 1925 and 1926, was given the name Makelita by locals in her memory. During a local marriage ceremony, Mead also wore a dress woven by the late queen. ==See also==