College and amateur Pyzdrowski attended
Fenwick High School in
Oak Park, Illinois, played club soccer for
HUSA soccer club, and played
college soccer at the
Marquette University from 2006 to 2009. He was named to the NSCAA All-Wisconsin team as a senior in 2009, and over his four years at Marquette received BIG EAST Goalkeeper of the Week honors on several occasions. He finished his career ranked fifth on the school's all-time list of goalkeepers with a 1.37 goals against average, 11 career shutouts and 206 career saves. During his college years Pyzdrowski also played one season with the
Chicago Fire Premier in the
USL Premier Development League.
Professional Pyzdrowski turned professional in 2010 when he signed with the
Portland Timbers in the
USSF Division-2 Professional League. He made his professional debut on April 22, 2010, in a game against
AC St. Louis. He made his first professional start on August 21, 2010, against Minnesota where he made 3 saves en route to his first career shutout and a 1–0 victory. Pyzdrowski left the Timbers following the conclusion of the 2010 USSFD2 season, and on March 1, 2011, signed with
Ängelholm of Sweden's
Superettan after a week-long trial where he impressed in a friendly match against Allsvenskan side Trelleborg FF and helped secure a 3–2 victory for Ängelholm. In Pyzdrowski's first season as a starter for Ängelholm he appeared in every minute of every game leading the squad to 15 wins, 8 draws and 7 losses while racking up 8 shutouts and a third-place finish in the Swedish Superettan. Ängelholm qualified for the Allsvenskan promotion playoffs where they fell just short against Allsvenskan side Syrianska FC, 4–3 over two games. After the season, he received the 2011 Ängelholms FF "player of the year" award. Pyzdrowski has worked as a goalkeeping analyst for
The Athletic since 2018. ==References==