Early career (2015–2020) Caster trained under
Brian Myers and
Pat Buck at their Create A Pro Wrestling Academy and made his debut for the school's promotion in February 2015, later becoming the inaugural CAP Champion in December of that year. He wrestled on the
independent circuit for a number of promotions including
Combat Zone Wrestling. He also made a
WWE appearance as
Frances, one of
Bobby Lashley's (kayfabe) sisters, on the May 21, 2018 episode of
Raw.
All Elite Wrestling (2020–present) The Acclaimed (2020–2024) Caster made his first appearance for
All Elite Wrestling (AEW) on the June 23, 2020 episode of
Dark as a
heel, teaming with
Luther and Serpentico in a losing effort against
Jurassic Express (
Jungle Boy,
Luchasaurus and
Marko Stunt). He came back with his new tag team partner
Anthony Bowens on the October 27 episode of
Dark but lost to
Best Friends (
Chuck Taylor and
Trent). In November 2020, AEW President
Tony Khan announced that Caster, alongside Bowens, had been signed to a five-year contract with the promotion. The announcement also stated that Bowens and Caster would compete as a tag team named
The Acclaimed. The following week, Caster and Bowens unsuccessfully challenged
The Young Bucks (Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson) for the
AEW World Tag Team Championship. On the March 3, 2021, episode of
Dynamite, Caster defeated
10 to qualify for the Face of the Revolution
ladder match at
Revolution. However, at Revolution, the match was won by
Scorpio Sky. At
Double or Nothing on May 30, Caster competed in the
Casino Battle Royale, but he was eliminated by
Christian Cage. On the August 3 episode of
Dark, while making his entrance, Caster rapped about subjects such as Olympic gymnast
Simone Biles' mental health issues, the
Duke lacrosse case, the validity of
PCR COVID-19 testing, and made a sexual joke about
Julia Hart. AEW owner
Tony Khan called the rap "terrible", said it should have been edited out of the show and announced that he would personally be taking over the editing of the show. Caster was later removed from several independent events and AEW programming following the incident. He returned to action at
Dark: Elevation on September 1. Beginning in 2022, the Acclaimed allied with the
Gunn Club (
Billy Gunn and his sons
Austin Gunn and
Colten Gunn). On
Dark and
Dark: Elevation, the alliance defeated
the Dark Order and later the team of
Lee Johnson,
Brock Anderson,
Lee Moriarty, and
Matt Sydal. Their alliance with the Gunns broke down and turned into a rivalry in mid-2022, leading to a "Dumpster Match" in August 2022, which the Acclaimed won. While Billy Gunn was initially caught between the two groups, his sons turned on him, having joined
the Firm, leading to him becoming the Acclaimed's manager. In the latter half of 2022, the Acclaimed entered a feud with tag team champions Swerve in our Glory (
Swerve Strickland and
Keith Lee). At
All Out of that year the Acclaimed challenged for tag team championships, although Strickland and Lee retained. After All Out, The Acclaimed turned
face due to the favorable crowd reactions they would receive. The On September 21, 2022, at
Grand Slam, The Acclaimed would win the AEW World Tag Team Championship from Swerve In Our Glory. On February 8, 2023, after 140 days as champions, they lost the championships to
Colten and
Austin Gunn on
Dynamite. At
All In, Caster, Bowens and Billy won the
AEW World Trios Championship from
The House of Black. At
Dynasty:
Zero Hour on April 21, 2024,
ROH World Six-Man Tag Team Champions Bullet Club Gold (
Jay White, Austin Gunn and Colten Gunn) defeated Caster, Bowens, and Billy for the AEW World Trios Championship in a
winner takes all championship unification match to unify the titles as the Unified World Trios Championship, ending their reign at a record 238 days. The Acclaimed then began a feud with
The Young Bucks, defeating them on the June 19 episode of
Dynamite, in an eliminator match to earn a future shot at the AEW World Tag Team Championship. The Acclaimed were also a part of Team AEW that defeated
The Elite in a
Blood and Guts match on July 24 at the
namesake event. On the August 14 episode of
Dynamite, The Acclaimed's title match against The Young Bucks ended in a disqualification loss due to interference from
FTR (
Dax Harwood and
Cash Wheeler). On August 25 at
All In, The Acclaimed once again failed to win the titles from The Young Bucks in a
three-way tag team match, also involving FTR.
"Best Wrestler Alive" (2024–present) Between November 2024 and January 2025, Caster began to tease a
heel turn, referring to himself as the "best wrestler alive" and declared himself as the leader of The Acclaimed. On January 18 (taped January 16) at the
Collision edition of
Maximum Carnage, Caster cemented his heel turn and disbanded The Acclaimed after Bowens chose to side with Gunn over him. After disbanding The Acclaimed, Caster began his open challenge series on
Dynamite and
Collision, losing to various wrestlers such as
Rush,
"Hangman" Adam Page,
Brody King,
Jay White,
Konosuke Takeshita,
Hook,
Mark Briscoe,
Hologram and
Daniel Garcia. On April 6 at
Dynasty Zero Hour, Caster was defeated by former Acclaimed stablemate, Bowens, in his open challenge. On July 12 at
All In, Caster competed in the men's
Casino Gauntlet match. which was won by
MJF.{{Cite web |last=Powell |first=Jason |date=2025-07-12 |title=AEW All In Texas results: Powell's live review of Jon Moxley vs. Hangman Page in a Texas Death Match for the AEW World Championship, Toni Storm vs. TBS Champion Mercedes Mone for the AEW Women's Title ==Personal life==