Upon its release, Jerry Smith of
Music Week described "Me and My Foolish Heart" as a "polished pop tune" which "drives along, helped by a dynamic production and a strong vocal that is well underpinned by dramatic piano". He added that it "could well be an unexpected hit if given the necessary exposure".
Music & Media picked the song as one of their "records of the week" in their issue of 26 April 1986 and commented, "It is a highly polished and soaring melody in the
Fiction Factory/
OMD-trail that is sure to pick up good airplay."
Richard Cook of
Sounds called it an "excellent record" and remarked that the band "follow through the modesty of the song's title [with] music where everything is billowing melody, cascades of keyboard and guitar string and murmurs of remorse from a singer". He added, "A tawdry romance touched with magic for a single instant." Dave Morgan of the
Reading Evening Post described the song as "chugging synth stuff that never rises much above the standard required to appear on
Wogan". John Lee of the
Huddersfield Daily Examiner considered it to be "a bit wishy-washy, relying for its impact on a few echoey notes on the piano". He added, "Interesting enough I suppose, but not really the stuff to turn the hit parade on its predictable head." ==Track listing==