Save Me from Myself received mixed reception from critics. Some praised the album's message, "Even though the music of
Save Me from Myself isn't quite on par with the super hit material of Korn from the late '90s, it is nevertheless a very good nü-metal album with an amazing story of redemption." Andrea Goforth of
Christianity Today stated, "The content is so much more positive that anything released by Korn, that I can look past the absence of hooks to find a great deal of hope." It has been proposed that the album has a distinctive sound, very reminiscent to
Korn, but different in the matter that its uplifting. The general praise of
Save Me from Myself has not been unanimous, however. Reviewing for
Metal Edge, Madeline Phillips felt that, "Sadly, in pursuit of greater spiritual understanding . . . Welch seems to have lost all sense of a relatable musical identity and direction," and that despite some noteworthy
riffs and decent melodies, the album is "not just alienating - quite frankly, it's boring."
Save Me from Myself shipped over 7,800 copies in its opening week. It debuted at No. 27 in New Zealand, No. 7 on the
Independent Albums chart, This prompted Welch to provide his explanation for what transpires in the video: ==Track listing==