According to producer
Eric Saward, series producer
John Nathan-Turner had told him that he wanted to have a "redhead companion" on the series. Nathan-Turner had immediately suggested
Bonnie Langford. Langford at the time was a well-known, veteran actor, which authors at
SFX considered to be part of John Nathan-Turner's plans to get
Doctor Who talked about in the press. Langford was also known for having a strong scream, which multiple authors believed was a factor in her casting. A new script editor was hired to the series following Season 24 who wished to take the series in a different direction. As a result, Mel's character was written to adapt to the episodes as written, and was given no character arc. with Mel's role in the original series being considered by Langford to be akin to a "diversion," which led to Langford feeling as though she couldn't "find her footing" in the role of Mel. Mel was eventually removed from the series; while it has been stated that poor audience reaction to Mel's role in the classic series led to the character's hasty removal from the series, co-star
Sylvester McCoy has stated that the reason for her departure was because "[Langford] couldn't take it anymore," with Langford electing to leave the show of her own accord. In a later interview, Langford stated she left the series because producers had not asked her to stay on for another season, and Langford wished to guarantee she had another role lined up following her role on
Doctor Who. The producers were originally content to let Langford leave according to McCoy; Mel had no departure scene in the original script of
Dragonfire. She also stated that she preferred playing Mel in the revived series than in the classic series due to Mel's maturation, and also responded positively to the support she had received from fans for her role Davies originally planned to kill Mel at the end of
"Empire of Death" (2024), but decided against it during writing of the episode. During the in-episode commentary for "Empire of Death", Davies hinted that the mystery of Mel's family would play a role in the future of the series. == Reception ==