In the 18th century Ignacio Lopez de Ayala identified Mellaria with the town of Tarifa, where coins, foundations and other ancient relics had been found. This theory was discounted at the time since the town of
Iulia Traducta was thought to have occupied the site of Tarifa. It has therefore been common to locate Mellaria in the west of the municipality of Tarifa, near Casas de Porro, where the Río del Valle enters the sea. Relics from the classical era have been found here, including ceramics and a cyst grave. However, the coast seems to have been fairly densely settled at that time, so these could well be remains of some other town. In his
Natural History,
Pliny the Elder states that the narrowest part of the Strait was between the
vicus of Mellaria and the
Promunturium Album on the coast of Africa. This would clearly indicate that Mellaria was at the tip of Tarifa. According to
Strabo, Menralia [sic] lay between
Carteia and Belo.
Pomponius Mela places Mellaria between Tingentera, another name for Iulia Traducta, and
Baelo Claudia. He also said that Tingentera was in the same bay as Carteia, the
Bay of Gibraltar.
Ptolemy also located Mellaria between Traducta and Baelo. Assuming that Traducta Iulia was located in the Bay of Algeciras, it is therefore reasonable to identify Mellaria with Tarifa. ==History==