In its
starred review,
Kirkus Reviews called it "vividly written" and wrote, "Washington's novel is richly layered and thrives in the quiet moments between lovers and family members." In its starred review,
Publishers Weekly wrote that Washington applied "nuance in equal measure to his characters and the places they're tied to". Michael Schaub of
NPR called the novel a "masterpiece" and praised Washington's "ability to draw the reader's attention to what's not said as much as what is".
Ron Charles of
The Washington Post praised the novel's narration, writing, "Washington inhabits these two men so naturally that the sophistication of this form is rendered entirely invisible, and their narratives unspool as spontaneously and clearly as late-night conversation." In December 2020, Emily Temple of
Literary Hub reported that the novel had made 14 lists of the best books of 2020. The following year, it was longlisted for the
Aspen Words Literary Prize. ==Awards and nominations==