Keagle enjoyed a promising debut with the Chicks. In her first game, she smashed two
singles, a
double and one
home run to
drive in all four runs for Milwaukee in a 4–2 victory over Kenosha. The rest of the way she was almost unstoppable, ending with a .264
batting average in 109 games, and pace the league with seven home runs, 145
total bases and 19
extrabases. She also led her team in average, home runs, hits (107),
runs scored (72) and RBI (47), while ranking third in the batting crown race behind South Bend's
Betsy Jochum (.288) and Racine's
Eleanor Dapkus (.269). In 1945, Keagle did not play for the new
Grand Rapids Chicks. She stayed in Arizona to marry her fiancé, Richard, and give birth to their son. But she rejoined the Chicks in 1946 in good form, leading the league outfielders with a .284 average. She also posted a 3–2 record in six
pitching appearances, scored 69 runs, had career-numbers in hits (116) and RBI (59), shared the doubles title (15), ranked third in RBI, and made the All-Star Team. Although originally nicknamed
Pat by her teammates, she eventually was dubbed the
Blonde Bombshell by the Chicks fanatics, becoming one of the most beloved players in the team along with
Alice Haylett,
Inez Voyce,
Connie Wisniewski and
Alma Ziegler. Unfortunately, Keagle left the Chicks shortly before the end of the season, because she suffered extreme fatigue and early signs of cancer. Keagle spent 1947 in Arizona in an attempt to regain her health and return to baseball action. In 1948 she reported to the AAGPBL
spring training camp at
Opa-locka, Florida, showing her smiling face and carrying an extra 10 pounds. She remained as popular and mischievous as ever and quickly regained her old form. Nevertheless, her offensive production declined during the regular season. She scored a career-high 75 runs, but slipped to a .251 average with 23 extrabases and only 27 RBI over 116 games. With just nine games remaining of the schedule, she tore her left ankle from its socket while sliding at second base. In 1949 she did not return for the Chicks because her fragile health remained a deterrent to the league's demanding schedule. ==Life after baseball==