Messy Little Raindrops received mixed reviews from music critics. A predominantly positive review came from Jon O'Brien of
AllMusic who awarded it four out of five stars, saying that "
Messy Little Raindrops is a cohesive and adventurous follow-up that will undoubtedly continue [Cole's] ascent into pop's premier league", and praising the songs "Promise This", "Amnesia" and "Happy Tears". Tom Hocknell of
BBC Music was generally positive, labeling
Messy Little Raindrops a "competent and frequently enjoyable pop album". The
Daily Mirror also gave three stars, noting an improvement from
3 Words as well as Cole's perseverance. Although he saw an improvement from
3 Words, Montgomery felt the album did not live up to "the
Xenomania-directed wizardry of her
Girls Aloud oeuvre". It received two stars out of five from Andy Gill of
The Independent, who wrote that "Cole delve[s] further into her experience for Messy Little Raindrops; sadly, most of the album simply continues its predecessor's tedious romantic arguments, with only a couple of songs drawing on her more traumatic illness." A review from
The Scotsman agreed, criticizing the album as "a reasonable pop record that has had all the personality produced right out of it." Simon Price, also from
The Independent, was overwhelmingly negative. He summarised, "Messy Little Raindrops is music for yoghurt adverts, with lyrics for people who get their
emotional vocabulary from Take a Break and Loose Women."
Entertainment.ies Jenny Mulligan describes
Messy Little Raindrops as being "more club-friendly" and as "a pop album with a few banging singles and a lot of filler". == Singles ==