The Metropolitan Library System has been involved in a number of controversies and accusations of censorship. Many express concern that extreme
cultural conservatives exercise an inordinate amount of power over the system.
"The Tin Drum" controversy In 1997, the system was placed in the center of a dispute regarding the film "
The Tin Drum". The conservative group "Oklahomans for Children and Families" checked out the film, as well as other material from the Library, and began accusing the library of being a harbor for "obscene" material, including the film in question. Members of the group began attending meetings of city councils around Oklahoma County, and were able to convince a number of these cities to pass resolutions regarding the group's goals. Eventually one of the group's leaders turned over a copy of the film to local police. This resulted in the film being declared obscene by Oklahoma County District Judge Richard Freeman; as a result, all known copies of the film were seized from both libraries as well as individuals who had rented copies from video stores. However, the film's prohibited status was eventually revoked after the film's ban provoked further controversy and allegations of censorship.
"Controversial" Children's Books In August 2005, the Library Commission voted 10-7 to move "easy, easy-reader, and tween" books containing "sensitive or controversial" themes to an area that could only be accessed by adults. The decision was based primarily on concern by cultural conservatives that books that advocate acceptance of homosexuality, such as "
King and King", were accessible by children. Staff of the Library system opposed such restrictions, and the
American Library Association strongly condemned the decision. Prior, state representative
Sally Kern had spearheaded an effort to keep such books away from children; in May 2005, the Oklahoma House passed a nonbinding resolution to "confine homosexually themed books and other age-inappropriate material to areas exclusively for adult access and distribution", primarily due to Kern's efforts. The Commission's decision was implemented in February 2006 as a "Family Talk" section that contained such controversial content. Further restrictions were added in November 2008, when the Commission added the requirement that such material must be placed at least 60 inches off the ground in order to be out of the reach of many children. In December 2008, bloggers James Miko and Wayne Fuller accused Oklahoma City Mayor
Mick Cornett of working with Steve Kern, the husband of Rep. Sally Kern and pastor of Olivet Baptist Church in Oklahoma City, to make nominations to the Metropolitan Library Commission based on the issue of disallowing children access to such controversial books. The "Gossip Boy" blog had obtained a copy of a leaked conversation with Kern, where he mentioned his nominees for the Commission and mentioned that one "won’t take a lick of nonsense from the homos."
Attempted gag order on abortion information In July 2022, the library system ordered its workers not to provide information about abortion to guests, saying in a memo, "If a staff member gives any information on how to obtain an abortion, then that person may be found personally liable and will also make MLS liable." One librarian described the order as "dystopian" and noted that the order violated the
American Library Association's Principles of Intellectual Freedom. After public backlash, the library system hastily clarified that librarians could "provide factual information" but "should not offer opinions surrounding the law." ==References==