Pre-draft Bleacher Report ranked Carter as the 34th best cornerback prospect in the draft. NFL draft analysts projected him to be selected anywhere from the fifth to the seventh round of the 2021 NFL Draft.
NFL.com analyst Lance Zierlein projected Carter to be a fifth-round pick.
New York Jets 2021 The
New York Jets selected Carter in the fifth round (154th overall) of the
2021 NFL draft, a pick they previously acquired as part of a trade that sent
Leonard Williams to the
New York Giants. Coincidentally, the Jets drafted another
Michael Carter from rival school
North Carolina in the fourth round of the draft earlier that day. He was the first of three cornerbacks the Jets drafted in 2021. On May 7, 2021, the New York Jets signed Carter to a four–year, $3.80 million
rookie contract that included an initial
signing bonus of $328,927. Throughout training camp, he competed against
Bryce Hall,
Blessuan Austin,
Javelin Guidry,
Jason Pinnock,
Isaiah Dunn, and
Brandin Echols to be a starting cornerback and was the favorite to win the role as the starting nickelback with Javelin Guidry as his top competition. Head coach
Robert Saleh named Carter as the third cornerback and starting nickelback, with Echols and Hall starting outside. On September 12, 2021, Carter made his professional regular season debut in the New York Jets' season-opener at the
Carolina Panthers and made five combined tackles (two solo) during a 14–19 loss. In Week 3, Carter earned his first career start, starting at nickelback, and recorded six combined tackles (two solo) during a 0–26 loss at the
Denver Broncos. On December 5, 2021, he recorded two combined tackles (one solo) before exiting in the third quarter of a 18–33 loss against the
Philadelphia Eagles in order to be evaluated for a possible
concussion. He was officially diagnosed with a concussion and entered concussion protocol, as he remained inactive as the Jets lost 9–30 to the
New Orleans Saints. On December 21, 2021, the Jets officially placed Carter on the
COVID-19/reserve list and he remained inactive as the Jets defeated the
Jacksonville Jaguars 26–21 in Week 16. On January 2, 2022, he collected a season-high eight combined tackles (six solo) and had his first career sack on
Tom Brady for a five-yard loss during a 28–24 loss against the
Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He finished his rookie season with a total of 72 combined tackles (45 solo), five pass deflections, two fumble recoveries, and one sack in 15 games and seven starts. He earned an overall grade of 53.7 from
Pro Football Focus as a rookie, ranked 98th among 116 qualifying cornerbacks in 2021. For the second straight year, Carter started at nickelback, this time with Reed and rookie
Sauce Gardner playing on the outside. On October 2, 2022, Carter made five solo tackles, a pass deflection, and had his first career interception off a pass thrown by
Kenny Pickett to tight end
Pat Freiermuth to help secure a 24–20 victory at the end of the fourth quarter at the
Pittsburgh Steelers. The following week, he recorded three combined tackles (two solo) and had a season-high two pass deflections as the Jets defeated the
Miami Dolphins 40–17 in Week 5. In Week 8, he collected a season-high seven solo tackles, broke up a pass, and intercepted a pass thrown by
Mac Jones to wide receiver
Kendrick Bourne during a 22–17 loss to the
New England Patriots. He finished the
2022 NFL season with a total of 63 combined tackles (50 solo), nine pass deflections, and two interceptions in 17 games and six starts. He earned an overall grade of 73.5 from Pro Football Focus, which ranked 19th among 118 qualifying cornerbacks in 2022. In Week 15, he tied his season-high of five solo tackles as the Jets lost 0–30 at the
Miami Dolphins. The following week, Carter made two solo tackles and set a season-high with three pass deflections during a 30–28 victory against the
Washington Commanders in Week 16. He finished the
2023 NFL season with 50 combined tackles (37 solo) and nine pass deflections in 15 games and seven starts. He received an overall grade of 80. 4 from
Pro Football Focus, which ranked 12th among qualifying cornerbacks.
2024 On September 3, 2024, the New York Jets signed Carter to a three–year, $30.75 million contract extension that includes $13.61 million guaranteed upon signing and an initial
signing bonus of $6.00 million. Head coach Robert Saleh named Carter as the Jets' starting nickelback. On October 8, 2024, the Jets announced their decision to fire head coach
Robert Saleh after the team began the season with a 2–3 record and subsequently appointed defensive coordinator
Jeff Ulbrich to interim head coach. He was inactive for two games (Weeks 6–7) after suffering an injury to his back. In Week 8, Carter collected a season-high five combined tackles (three solo) as the Jets lost 22–25 at the
New England Patriots. He re-aggravated his back injury and missed two more games (Weeks 16 and 18) to end the season. He ended the
2024 NFL season with 24 combined tackles (20 solo), a pass deflection, and a fumble recovery in 13 games and one start. He received an overall grade of 50.7 from Pro Football Focus, which ranked 183rd among 223 qualifying cornerbacks in 2024.
Philadelphia Eagles On October 29, 2025, Carter and a 2027 seventh-round pick were traded to the
Philadelphia Eagles in exchange for
John Metchie III and a 2027 sixth-round pick. During the 2026 offseason, following the departure of starting safety
Reed Blankenship in
free agency,
The Athletic's Zach Berman reported that the Eagles were likely to move Carter to the
safety position. ==References==