As Fahey recounts, "I was in the back of a record store in July and I saw all these cartons of Bing Crosby's White Christmas albums. The clerk said it always sells out. So I got the idea to do a
Christmas album that would sell every year."
The New Possibility has been one of Fahey's best selling recordings, selling over 100,000 copies initially, and has been continually in print. Fahey's original liner notes discuss the German-American theologian and
Christian existentialist philosopher Paul Tillich's reference to the birth of Jesus Christ as "The New Possibility". Fahey notes the scholarly research on the secular and mythological/superstitious ideas connected with the "Christmas Story". These liner notes were removed in later reissues. When asked why, Fahey said, "I just didn't feel that way any more." In 1979, Fahey said, "Well, the arrangements are pretty good, but on the other hand there are more mistakes on this album than on any of the other 17 albums I’ve recorded. And yet, here’s the paradox… this album has not only sold more than any of my others, I meet people all the time who are crazy about it. I mean really love it. What can I say. I’m confused." Fahey recorded three more Christmas albums, in addition to re-recording the tracks of
The New Possibility as
Christmas Guitar, Volume One. There were numerous reissues on
LP,
8-track tape, and
cassette. Some later reissues confusingly used the cover art from the 1975 album
Christmas with John Fahey Vol. II. A 2000
CD reissue of
The New Possibility includes the entire contents of both that album and
Christmas with John Fahey Vol. II. ''John Fahey's Guitar Christmas Book
, a folio of guitar transcriptions of songs from The New Possibility
and Christmas with John Fahey Vol. II'', was published by Stropes Editions in 1981. It is no longer in print. ==Reception==