Reeves is best known for his third and final movie,
Witchfinder General. He was only 24 years old when he co-wrote and directed it. In 2005,
Total Film magazine named
Witchfinder General the 15th-greatest horror film of all time. Made on a modest budget in
East Anglia and adapted from the novel by
Ronald Bassett,
Witchfinder General tells the story of
Matthew Hopkins, the lawyer-turned-witchhunter who blackmails and murders his way across the countryside. Reeves imbues the film with a powerful sense of the impossibility of behaving morally in a society whose conventions have broken down, and though it is by no means free of the conventions of low-budget horror, it stands as a notably powerful and evocative film. Reeves wanted
Donald Pleasence to play the title role, but
American International Pictures, the film's co-financiers, insisted on using their resident horror star
Vincent Price instead. This caused friction between the actor and the young director. A famous story is told of how Reeves won Price's respect: Reeves was constantly telling Price to tone down his over-acting, and to play the role more seriously. Price eventually cracked, snapping, "Young man, I have made eighty-four films. What have you done?" Reeves replied: "I've made three good ones." Reeves continued to goad Price into delivering a vicious and brilliant performance, and only upon seeing the finished film did the actor realise what the director was up to, at which point Price took steps to bury the hatchet with Reeves.
Witchfinder General was released to mixed reviews, with one notably savage notice by
Alan Bennett appearing in
The Listener, but was soon reassessed and gained generally favourable reviews. ==Death==