Raised in the
Mullica Hill section of
Harrison Township, New Jersey, Tumolo began her career in the summer of 2005 before her freshman year at
Clearview Regional High School, where she was a three-time captain. In her junior year, she participated in the 2008 National High School Girls' Lacrosse Tournament. Playing under the coaching of Megan Conklin, she would graduate with school records for goals (270), assists (121), ground balls (364), and draw controls (308).
NCAA Tumolo played with the Syracuse Orange from 2010 to 2013 under head coach
Gary Gait. In her debut season, Tumolo would post the highest single-season totals in points and assists for a freshman in program history. With the Orange, Tumolo played for a pair of Big East Championship teams in 2012 and 2013. In addition, she appeared with the Orange in the 2012 NCAA Championship game in 2012, complemented by a pair of NCAA Final Four competitions in 2010 and 2013. In her senior season with the Orange playing against Cornell on April 13, 2013, Tumolo tore her ACL. This injury sidelined her for the rest of her senior season. Graduating fifth on the program's all-time scoring list with 278 points, Tumolo is just the second player in school history to record 200 points, 100 goals and 100 assists in her career. In 2012, Tumolo became the first player in program history to earn the National Attacker of the Year award. That season, she scored a career-high 95 points while leading the Orange in assists with 43, respectively.
USA Lacrosse Though she suffered an ACL tear in 2013, Tumolo bounced back to make the US national team. Along with Orange alums
Liz Hogan and
Katie Rowan, Tumolo was one of two current stars with the Orange, joined by Becca Block that were named to the team in the summer of 2015. Tumolo proudly wears the number 35 jersey. She is a key player on the attacking end. During a five-game tour in England in 2016, Tumolo scored nine goals for Team USA and had six assists. Also in 2016 during the Team USA Fall Classic, Tumolo contributed seven goals and led the team with 10 assists. ==Coaching career==