Mary Shelley's gender concerns did not cease with generic issues. In the musical contest between
Apollo and
Pan in the first act, Apollo is associated with masculine characteristics, such as philosophy, science, and reason, and Pan is associated with feminine characteristics, such as sheep and nature. however, as Purinton notes, "both sing egocentric lyrics that boast of their 'instruments' and their deeds". When Apollo wins, the play appears to celebrate "male superiority". However, Pan appeals the decision to King
Midas, who reverses the decision in Pan's favour, for which he is then punished. Shelley also uses the figure of Midas to comment on capitalism and
imperialism. Midas's initial joy in acquiring gold is symbolic of contemporary England, "racing headlong into its new identity as an industrialized, consumerist society financed by political and mercantile imperialism". For Shelley, these commercial efforts are particularly masculine; Midas's ears, which symbolise emasculation, are juxtaposed to masculinising gold. Furthermore, Shelley suggests that when political leaders become feminised, they lose their political power. She draws an analogy between Midas and
George III and
George IV, British kings who were often viewed as feminised. Like Percy Shelley,
John Keats, and
Lord Byron, Mary Shelley was rewriting the classical myths; however, like other Romantic women writers, she was challenging
patriarchy in particular.
Midas is not just a commentary on
Ovid's version of the tale in the
Metamorphoses; it is also a commentary on
Geoffrey Chaucer's version in ''
The Wife of Bath's Tale''. In Ovid's version it is Midas's barber who cannot keep the secret of his ears; in Chaucer's version, it is his wife. In Mary Shelley's version, it is Midas's prime minister who cannot keep the secret; however, Midas is convinced a woman has revealed his secret and a courtier explicitly states "There is no woman here".
Proserpine and
Midas are often seen as a pair of contrasting plays.
Proserpine is a play of female bonding, while
Midas is a male-dominated drama; male poets participate in a contest in
Midas while in
Proserpine female characters participate in communal storytelling; "where Midas lives in his golden palace imagining himself at the center of an all-powerful court,
Ceres laments leaving the pastoral enclave she shares with
Proserpine for Jove's court"; Midas focuses on gold, while the women in
Proserpine enjoy flowers; and "where the society of
Midas is marked by egotism, greed, and strife, the female society of
Proserpine values community, gift-giving, and love". ==Reception==